Dear Agilent
You are welcome to express your views. Being a newcomer to the forum should not hold you from expressing your views. Sharing thoughts, views, knowledge makes this forum unique.
Even I would like to share a few thoughts with you.
First regarding terse/concise comments. We can always just say Buy or Sell or Hold. If you had noticed in this forum we always try to backup our comments with reason. It not only substantiates the analysis/comment but also provides an opportunity for others to understand and learn. Without the reason it would amount to providing TIPS, which we abhor in this forum. So concise/terse/brief comments are seldom possible.
Secondly regarding the Fundamental inputs. Most queries raised in this forum are for short to medium term where the effect of fundamental inputs is not very significant. In the short to medium term TA helps us much better as it is the reflection of the current greed and fear situation of the market. That is why the concentration on TA is more. I am not ruling the effect of fundamentals fully. Of-course when we talk about long term that the Fundamentals assume much more significance. We will definitely try to provide fundamental inputs as far as possible.
By the way, Amit had always given the fundamental inputs wherever required. We can debate this for long but if I do that I wont be concise, isnt it?
You must have noticed that Traderji has opened a new sub forum just for discussing individual stocks. Here we should encourage members to post their views both fundamental and technical on individual stocks.
Warm regards
Karthik