Going With The 60min Flow!!!

Which Futures do u all trade with real Money?

  • MiniNifty

    Votes: 28 40.6%
  • Nifty

    Votes: 50 72.5%
  • Aban

    Votes: 16 23.2%
  • L&T

    Votes: 18 26.1%
  • Hdil

    Votes: 6 8.7%
  • JP asso

    Votes: 6 8.7%
  • RIL

    Votes: 5 7.2%
  • Relcap

    Votes: 11 15.9%
  • Suzlon

    Votes: 6 8.7%
  • Educomp

    Votes: 8 11.6%

  • Total voters
    69
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

pakatil

Well-Known Member
ps:I will no more post in this thread,except on weekends......Then,I am going to post here the trades that should have been over the week......And we can then compare notes.
Dear Saint,

I am simply amazed at your unlimited patience. Isn't this bombardment in the glorified garb of debating/discussing/doubt-raising enough to wear out the patience.

Honestly we don't deserve any kind of consideration. We seem to have grown bigger than our shoes.

Reagards
 

rh6996

Well-Known Member
I think this kind of Reversal has been done a couple of times already. I can't remember exactly when.

Hope my memory serves me right. :D
Please rake up your memory and post the trades!!!! None there in the charts posted by Saint!!!!
Your memory does not seem to be serving you right!!!! Remember this is not mini flow as pointed out by Bee too to Inspire!!!
 

rh6996

Well-Known Member
Inspire, Rk, RH, Pakatil,

I will try and attempt to clear this but Saint is the final authority. On 31.10.2008 morning we had the following scenario playing out:

Scenario 3:You are holding longs and market gaps up visually......Reversal below the frst 5min bar's low with stops at 5min bar's high. If lows trigger by Rs20,exit longs and enter short.Nothing to be done if price gaps up and keeps shooting up.

The above is as per the last rules of saint.

Now the low of the first bar (5 min) was not taken out by next two bars. But now we have a Pivot (not a visual Pivot but a pivot to work on in case of a downturn. The SAR was defined by the low of these bars 2858 15, please note it is no longer 20 but 15 as the first move is already towards the up and this is the down (second) move. BUT we have a pivot to work on. Please go beyond what saint says he cannot explain everything by writing. This lesson of an elongated pivot (pivot constituting many bars) was drilled to us a few days back by Saint.

Now Inspires question as to why we cannot go long above the break of resting bar --- this method is flow method, we already have a SAR ( pivot) in place which is the HOD of the day + room. We do not reverse on break of anything except pivot.

The situation in the morning was different we had to get new PIVOT (SAR point) to latch on to as soon as we can in a gap up scenario where we do not have an apparent PIVOT to start with.

I hope I have tried to convey the idea. Friends, there is no contradiction in what Saint has said till now and yesterdays trade.

In fact it is us who do not extend the argument or the direction Saint has pointed us towards.

Cheers

Bee
We had a PL just 2 bars back , at previous days 3 PM low!!! We had a PL to latch on to....why use a mini flow method!!! And by no imagination can you call the 11 AM bar low as a PL, the only rule that defines it is : Saint says so!!!! Why had not all seen the Pivot before Saint pointed it out!!!
 

musicjunkie

Well-Known Member
I have no words, too numb to talk. Dunno if we would have your active participation in the miniflow, we still (or atleast I) need more experience to stand up to daytrade on my own.
Saint, I really can't ask you to be here if you don't want to, but I just hope everything goes well in the end.

Thank you for all your teachings, Hope we can live upto your expectations in the coming weeks.

Regards,
MJ-
 

rh6996

Well-Known Member
Hi,

That was the thing done yesterday.(in bold)No mistake from Saint at all.
Why is the confusion I do not know:confused:

Regards.
I have three examples in my view where there was a bigger gap and similar action was not taken!!!! We waited for a Pivot to reverse!!!!
People here are so easy on thanks, that when Saint says : I am not well , and people thank him!!
Yes there is confusion, you just cannot wish it away!!!
 

musicjunkie

Well-Known Member
I have three examples in my view where there was a bigger gap and similar action was not taken!!!! We waited for a Pivot to reverse!!!!
People here are so easy on thanks, that when Saint says : I am not well , and people thank him!!
Yes there is confusion, you just cannot wish it away!!!
Remove your exclamation marks. Your language could be a little more refined. Refined language however is more a matter of nurturing.
Please a little more kind when you put your view forward.

MJ-
 

beethoven

Well-Known Member
Friends,

I am flabbergasted at what this has cascaded into overnight. If I am responsible in any way for this then I am very sorry. I just thought I would put in my interpretation of the situation. I am a learner and do not claim that my interpretation is correct. Just my view that is all. I trade real money as paper trade does not go into my head, I loose focus fast. So in the ultimate analysis it will be the money that I make at the end of the day with the skills learned here which will decide how much I have learned and how much I still require to learn (which I believe is lots).

I have followed this thread from the very beginning but only recently have started active posting.

I again apologise if someone's feelings are hurt.

Bee

Saint,

I would humbly request you to overlook this sad situation for which I am also partly responsible - unknowingly though. A great teacher like you should forgive errant students, and start posting live and not on weekends as that would be a disaster.

Bee
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads