dear hari
sorry for disturbing you so much... as i said earlier am following mini flow from the last 2 weeks.. but still not crystal clear about the system.. i have the following doubts
1. About moving filters..
eventhough in todays trade you ended in profit( you longed at 2675) it was not correct as per my understandings.. what made you take that decision? how the moving filters were applied? is it using 15m Tf or 30min Tf before 11a.m?what was your mistake? and how to apply moving filters properly? please explain in simple understandable way( with TFs)
2.About 2 bar & 4 bar rules
when and how these rules are applied.. i couldnt understand 2 bars rule much... 4 bar rule is ok
3.About SAR
i am still confused in using TFs.. which TF should we use after 10.00 to 11 for applying moving filters?
Is it wise to reverse whenever stop is hit? i mean in extreme volatile days it may hit several times and we end in loss!!
4. About saints class
which are the rules amended by him?
hari, please answer for each of the above questions whenever you get time . one question per day will be sufficient for me.. Is it the wrong thread to ask such questions??? if i am mistaken tell me where to post .
In you library thread kindly include summery of trades we undertook in tough days (as on 6-11-08 and 20-11-08) categorizing them under
a. uptrend
b. downtrend
c. sideways move
one example for each category will be sufficient
Wishing you all success for your library thread.
regards
bijo
well this is asked to hari...let me clear myself too bijo & then let hari clear for us both..so dont mind bijo even i made some serious mis understanding...just confirms its hard when trading pratically ..nevertheless how many times we read theory...
=> 2 bar & 4 bar method is one and same : its like we shift the sar 2 bars down the 4th bar or up (which is hh hl or lh ll (as per long and short position exception 60min blah blah (as hari put in during trading hrs)
1) moving filter is always on 30 ...
=> moving filter : its being stated clearly to shift moving filter as per 30 min TF but i was following 15 tf from beginning and was moving filter at every 15 min interval ..so no short triggered for me. remember we trade 15 tf from 10 to 11 ...means look for pivots and all ....it dosent mean we shift our filters on 15 min tf...(now this is as per my understanding)
=> saint put everything on 12 nov after amending rules...then only confusion
was argued regarding move 1 , move 2 & 2 bar method..then both cleared
in subsequent arguements...
=> as per rules yes we reverse the trades when sar is hit...but mostly after 3 pm many of them avoid taking new position...
=>abt yr doubt regarding long position...(its subjective for me ,you or anyone)
cuz different data levels...so its better hari or any senior answer it
harsh