Why market always exist? but traders always do not exist continuously
- Thread starter Tamil trader
- Start date
By your words you clearly proved as analyst....( ie escaping with gimmick words)
in india it is common that a stock exchange would go bankrupt then why not a stock....
your words shows you that you did not compare equity returns with Real estate... Can you post any period ( at least 10-15 years when equity market gave much better return than real estate??)
if one build an index that includes all Public limited companies which traded in BSE and NSE from 1990 will give a real picture about reality
Most of companies looted public money.... you like people gives example of warren buffet ,graham Dodd and Rakeshji..
Dad..... here most of us not such big Millionaires such as buffet most of us here looking for safe investment for their hard earned money
Pls guide us if you find any simple method that gives better return which beats inflation
don't ask us to work to study use less balance sheet or Company profile ( which are not reflecting any reality) to get a better return than FD
in india it is common that a stock exchange would go bankrupt then why not a stock....
your words shows you that you did not compare equity returns with Real estate... Can you post any period ( at least 10-15 years when equity market gave much better return than real estate??)
if one build an index that includes all Public limited companies which traded in BSE and NSE from 1990 will give a real picture about reality
Most of companies looted public money.... you like people gives example of warren buffet ,graham Dodd and Rakeshji..
Dad..... here most of us not such big Millionaires such as buffet most of us here looking for safe investment for their hard earned money
Pls guide us if you find any simple method that gives better return which beats inflation
don't ask us to work to study use less balance sheet or Company profile ( which are not reflecting any reality) to get a better return than FD
You are not alone 
I started with TA, learned everything I had to about TA and I actually made money but then I realized that this is hard, there is no margin of safety in TA, one little mistake can have serious consequences and not to mention that you have to constantly monitor your positions.
FA on the other hand provides a margin of safety. If you invest in the right company you dont have to monitor it daily. If you invest at the right price you can ignore the daily market fluctuations. e.g In wipro I went from an unrealized profit of 20% to an unrealized loss of 20% to a realized profit of 40%. Ofcourse you need to be cool and not panic when you have an unrealized 20% loss.
Why do you want to invest your money randomly?
By reading the financial statements and the annual report.
That is the risk of equity market, is there a rule that markets will go up all the time. Why dont you look at the 10 year Nifty return.
Can tell the names of those companies.
Seriously?? If the investors of Kingfisher read the balance sheet and income statement before investing they would not have lost their money in KFA.
Even an average person can figure out from the above image that KFA is a bad company to invest.
You had plenty of time to exit from Tata Steel, tata steel had net profit margin of over 20% in 2005, it kept dropping every year and in 2010 it finally went negative. Why do you want to invest in such a company. You can know such things only through FA and not TA.
I havent studied bhel in much detail but a quick look tells me that its looking attractive at current valuation.
Ofcourse in the end what matters is that are you making money. If you are making money using TA, use TA.
I started with TA, learned everything I had to about TA and I actually made money but then I realized that this is hard, there is no margin of safety in TA, one little mistake can have serious consequences and not to mention that you have to constantly monitor your positions.
FA on the other hand provides a margin of safety. If you invest in the right company you dont have to monitor it daily. If you invest at the right price you can ignore the daily market fluctuations. e.g In wipro I went from an unrealized profit of 20% to an unrealized loss of 20% to a realized profit of 40%. Ofcourse you need to be cool and not panic when you have an unrealized 20% loss.
Why do you want to invest your money randomly?
By reading the financial statements and the annual report.
That is the risk of equity market, is there a rule that markets will go up all the time. Why dont you look at the 10 year Nifty return.
Can tell the names of those companies.
Seriously?? If the investors of Kingfisher read the balance sheet and income statement before investing they would not have lost their money in KFA.
Even an average person can figure out from the above image that KFA is a bad company to invest.
You had plenty of time to exit from Tata Steel, tata steel had net profit margin of over 20% in 2005, it kept dropping every year and in 2010 it finally went negative. Why do you want to invest in such a company. You can know such things only through FA and not TA.
I havent studied bhel in much detail but a quick look tells me that its looking attractive at current valuation.
Ofcourse in the end what matters is that are you making money. If you are making money using TA, use TA.
Last edited:
You are not alone
I started with TA, learned everything I had to about TA and I actually made money but then I realized that this is hard, there is no margin of safety in TA, one little mistake can have serious consequences and not to mention that you have to constantly monitor your positions.
FA on the other hand provides a margin of safety. If you invest in the right company you dont have to monitor it daily. If you invest at the right price you can ignore the daily market fluctuations. e.g In wipro I went from an unrealized profit of 20% to an unrealized loss of 20% to a realized profit of 40%. Ofcourse you need to be cool and not panic when you have an unrealized 20% loss.
Why do you want to invest your money randomly?
By reading the financial statements and the annual report.
That is the risk of equity market, is there a rule that markets will go up all the time. Why dont you look at the 10 year Nifty return.
Can tell the names of those companies.
Seriously?? If the investors of Kingfisher read the balance sheet and income statement before investing they would not have lost their money in KFA.
Even an average person can figure out from the above image that KFA is a bad company to invest.
You had plenty of time to exit from Tata Steel, tata steel had net profit margin of over 20% in 2005, it kept dropping every year and in 2010 it finally went negative. Why do you want to invest in such a company. You can know such things only through FA and not TA.
I havent studied bhel in much detail but a quick look tells me that its looking attractive at current valuation.
Ofcourse in the end what matters is that are you making money. If you are making money using TA, use TA.
I started with TA, learned everything I had to about TA and I actually made money but then I realized that this is hard, there is no margin of safety in TA, one little mistake can have serious consequences and not to mention that you have to constantly monitor your positions.
FA on the other hand provides a margin of safety. If you invest in the right company you dont have to monitor it daily. If you invest at the right price you can ignore the daily market fluctuations. e.g In wipro I went from an unrealized profit of 20% to an unrealized loss of 20% to a realized profit of 40%. Ofcourse you need to be cool and not panic when you have an unrealized 20% loss.
Why do you want to invest your money randomly?
By reading the financial statements and the annual report.
That is the risk of equity market, is there a rule that markets will go up all the time. Why dont you look at the 10 year Nifty return.
Can tell the names of those companies.
Seriously?? If the investors of Kingfisher read the balance sheet and income statement before investing they would not have lost their money in KFA.
Even an average person can figure out from the above image that KFA is a bad company to invest.
You had plenty of time to exit from Tata Steel, tata steel had net profit margin of over 20% in 2005, it kept dropping every year and in 2010 it finally went negative. Why do you want to invest in such a company. You can know such things only through FA and not TA.
I havent studied bhel in much detail but a quick look tells me that its looking attractive at current valuation.
Ofcourse in the end what matters is that are you making money. If you are making money using TA, use TA.
Thanx man! I did'nt know if anyone else used FA here aswell! You've given me hope after all!
Similar threads
-
How do you manage risk when trading forex, especially during volatile market conditions?
- Started by ReggieFx
- Replies: 1
-
What are the most effective strategies for identifying trends in the forex market?
- Started by ReggieFx
- Replies: 1
-
Ryan Anderson: In-Depth Analysis of the Impact of High-Interest Rates on the Market
- Started by Ryan Anderson
- Replies: 0
-
Fundamental Analysis: Gabriel India - Absorbing Market Shocks
- Started by atdalalstreet
- Replies: 0
-