Good morning Traderji, Seniors, and my all frnds. I ve posted 1 thread earlier also but i m very much disappointed that no one is giving me satisfactory answer. Plzzz forgive me if i m rude . May b becoz i m big looser thats y i m frustrated so plzz forgive me for my unhealthy behaivour. I read number of articles on net , in which i found that - 1. Technical Analysis is Artificial intellegence, 2. Technical analysis is Vodoo, 3. Someone has told me - Technical analyst aur koi kam accha kar sakta ho ya na kar sakta ho lekin technical analyst harne ke baad apni har ka karan bahut acchi tereh samjha sakta hai ,4. Someone has told me ki jab Technical analysis bani thi , tab intra day nahi bana tha-- tou fir intra day trading technical analysis ke through successful kaise ho sakti hai.5. Koi kehta hai ki every tipser is a looser - kyunki khudke pas paise bachte nahi lagane ko , tou wo doosre ko gyan deta hai(he is tipser becoze he is having knowledge of technical analyst) , 6. Koi kehta hai ki agar SEBI ke rules mein ye ho jaye ki har Technical analyst (advisor) ka 3 years ka successful record hona chahiye tou fir poore india mein ek bhi advisory company na rahe. 7. Koi kehta hai ki technical analysis ki books khud hare hue logon ne likhi hai .8. Koi kehta hai ki jo log technical analysis ki classes provide karvate hain plus technical analysis par based tips dete hain wo log khud kyun nahi bazar se kama lete.------------- Halaki kuch log aise bhi hain jo technical analysis ko accha bhi kehte hain. I M SO MUCH CONFUSED . Kuch log ye bhi kehte hain ki Sachin Tendulkar ke guru khud kabhi sachin tendulkar nahi ban sakte, isliye teachers ko galat thahrana galat hai. Agr koi IAS (INDIAN ADMINISTRATION SERVICES) ki preparation karta hai aur mehnat karta hai tou wo sure pas hoga, lekin kya agar koi Technical analysis ki study karta hai ,aur mehnat karta hai tou kya wo is bazar mein sure paas hoga? . Kahi aisa tou nahi ki main sari zindgi Technical analysis seekhne mein nikal dun aur uske baad mujhe pata chale ki ye cheej hi galat hai ------ Progress has little to do with speed but much to do with direction so its always better to concentrate on direction rather than speed . Main 1 year ye janne mei laga dun ki Technical analysis kaam karti hai ya nahi karti ye kahi behtar hai is baat se ki main 10 saal baad ye sochun ki main Technical analysis ki teref galat enter hua. Plzz senior members i need your interference in this matter. Main aaj aap logon ki teref bahut umeedon se dekh raha hun . Plzz main chahunga sabse ki sach bolne ka sahas jutayein - aur bhi sach hai use samne layeing , chahe wo kitna bhi badttar kyun na ho. I request seniors ki plzz sir view karke is thread ko na jayein, reply zaroor karein . Plzz wo log reply na karein jinhe knowledge na ho ki Technical analysis kaam karti bhi hai ya nahi, kyunki isse confusion aur barega. Aap logon ko ho sakta hai ki aisa lage ki main cycic hoon, main mafi chahunga jin logo ko main hurt kar raha hun. Plzz koi bhi bura na maniyega, aur plzz mujhe samajhne ki koshish kijiyega. Plzz forgive my language. Mujhe sirf 2 hi baaton ka jawab chahiye ----- 1. Technical analysis kaam karti hai ya nahi ,2. Agr karti hai tou kya intra day mein bhi karti hai ?------------ plzz reply my above 2 question in yes or no. Mujhe ghuma fira kar jawab milta hai tou samajh nahi aata. Mera Traderji par bahut bharosa hai, maine iske bare mein accha suna hai - tou socha ki ye ek zariya hoga sach janne ka. Maine ye sach janne ki pehle bhi bahut koshish ki , lekin mujhe nahi mila......... Main chahta hun ki sach janne ki shuruat yaha se ho aur ant bhi yahi ho, i mean mujhe kahi aur na jana pare iski vastvikta janne k liye. Maine kabhi kisi se nahi poocha ki Technical analysis kitni mushkil hai , kyunki usse mujhe fark nahi parta, kyunki rasta kitna bhi mushkil ho manzil mujhe mil hi jayegi----- lekin mainse sabse ye zaroor poocha ki Technical analysis kaam karti hai ya nahi karti.. Plzz i repeat mera intention kisi ko hurt karne ka nahi hai, if i hurt someone then i really feel sorry for that, plzz forgive me and forgive my language,,, aap logon ke reply par mera future khara hai.. Mujhe bahut umeedein hain aap logon se , aur mere father ko bahut umeedein hain mujhse.. thnx all of frnds , seniors and traderji..
My last attempt to know the truth behind technical analysis through forum(traderji)
- Thread starter Harshit Badoni
- Start date
Re: My last attempt to know the truth behind technical analysis through forum(traderj
Dear friend...
Effectiveness of technical analysis, like any other knowledge, depends on how its being used. People should not confuse with the fact that by merely just knowing the technical indicators and strategies one can be successful.
In my 4 years of trading .... I have realised what other experienced traders have often written, that knowledge is only 30% factor .. rest 70% factor is descipline and money management. I have personally lost money on strategies which have been time tested ..then I realised it was more to do with my descipline and money management.
As you said, teachers can give you knowledge but not descipline so no point blaming the sword when the holder doesnt know how and when to use it.
Cheers
SH
Dear friend...
Effectiveness of technical analysis, like any other knowledge, depends on how its being used. People should not confuse with the fact that by merely just knowing the technical indicators and strategies one can be successful.
In my 4 years of trading .... I have realised what other experienced traders have often written, that knowledge is only 30% factor .. rest 70% factor is descipline and money management. I have personally lost money on strategies which have been time tested ..then I realised it was more to do with my descipline and money management.
As you said, teachers can give you knowledge but not descipline so no point blaming the sword when the holder doesnt know how and when to use it.
Cheers
SH
Re: My last attempt to know the truth behind technical analysis through forum(traderj
Yaar, Harshit, paisa kamaaney nikle ho na market se toh ye drama kyon, ki wo yeh kehta hai, yeh wo kehta hai TA ke baare mein. Khud ka deemag aur aankhein use karo na, bhai. Agar theek lagta hai, toh theek hai TA. Nahin toh, nahin. Baat khatam. Kuch aur jugaad dekho jo kaam karta ho market mein.
TJ ke senior kya vailey baithe hain ki baal ki khaal nikaalein hazoor-e-wala ki khushi ke liye. Kabhi ghoomo 2-4 din TJ ke threads mein, sab bhare pade hai 3 saal se TA ki baaton se. Agar ismey dam na hota toh Saint aur ST jaise trader kab ke kangaal ho gaye hotey, aur bheekh maang rahe hote kisi mandir ke baahar!
aur haan, Bible pado. 2000 saal pehale koi likh gaya tha: Seek, and ye shall find. Knock, and it will be opened unto you.
Ab iska matalab mat poochana, gussa aa jaayega eagleone ko!
Yaar, Harshit, paisa kamaaney nikle ho na market se toh ye drama kyon, ki wo yeh kehta hai, yeh wo kehta hai TA ke baare mein. Khud ka deemag aur aankhein use karo na, bhai. Agar theek lagta hai, toh theek hai TA. Nahin toh, nahin. Baat khatam. Kuch aur jugaad dekho jo kaam karta ho market mein.
TJ ke senior kya vailey baithe hain ki baal ki khaal nikaalein hazoor-e-wala ki khushi ke liye. Kabhi ghoomo 2-4 din TJ ke threads mein, sab bhare pade hai 3 saal se TA ki baaton se. Agar ismey dam na hota toh Saint aur ST jaise trader kab ke kangaal ho gaye hotey, aur bheekh maang rahe hote kisi mandir ke baahar!
aur haan, Bible pado. 2000 saal pehale koi likh gaya tha: Seek, and ye shall find. Knock, and it will be opened unto you.
Ab iska matalab mat poochana, gussa aa jaayega eagleone ko!
Re: My last attempt to know the truth behind technical analysis through forum(traderj
harshit bhai..............ye batao......ki....kya koi batsman....out ho sakta hai agar woh....khud koi galti na kare......even....sachin tendulkar...kai baar khud ki galtiyon ke karan out ho gaye...wo bhi zero par.......90 se 100..ke beech bhi out ho gaye,...kai century..bhi maari, one day me double century bhi maari........kya aisa koi batsman hai jo kabhi out na hua ho.....to kya batting ki tips ya trics (means all shots)...kaam nahi karti.......ab baat bowling ki......aisa kaun sa bowler hai...jo kabhi bhi pita nahi.....aisi kaun se bowl hai jispar
chakka nahi pad sakta hai.....to kya bowling action aur line aur lenth sab bekaar hai.......
cricket is mind game.....so is trading.....technical analysis,may or may not work daily...
now i comes to your questions......
1. Technical analysis kaam karti hai ya nahi ,2. Agr karti hai tou kya intra day mein bhi karti hai ?------------
answer......yes for both......
explanation - bhai agar...KHALI KO BAT PAKDA DO AUR ZAHEER KHAN KE SAAMNE BHEJ DO....TO WOH KITNE RUN BANA...LEGA
AUR AGAR.. SEHWAAG KO BHEJO.....TO WO KITNE BANAYEGA.........WHAT IS DIFFERENCE,,,,,,IT IS KNOWLEDGE OF SHOTS.......EVEN KHALI CAN HIT THE BAAL HARDER THAN SEHWAAG,BUT HE DO NOT NO WHICH SHOT TO PLAY.........
SO IN TRADING......IF YOU DO NOT NO ABC OF TECHNICAL ANALYAIS....THEN YOU WILL SURELY BE A LOOSER........BUT IF YOU KNOW...EVEN USE OF MOVING AVERAGES.....THEN YOU CAN EARN SOME THING..(MAY BE VERY TINY)IN MARKET OR YOU CAN PROTECT YOUR CAPITAL.............NOW LIKE ABOVE EXAMPLE...YOUR EARNING DEPENDS UPON YOUR MIND,,AND YOUR KNOWLEDGE OF TECHNICAL ANALISIS.....
DAY TRADING IS NOTHING BUT A FARM OF TRADING.....LIKE SWING TRADING OR POSITIONAL TRADING.....THE DIFFERENCE IS ONLY THAT MANY TRADER PREFER LOWER TIMEFRAMES IN DAY TRADING..........SO TECHNICAL ANALYSIS WORK HERE TOO
NOW ASSUME DAY TRADING AS 20-20..FORMAT OF CRICKET......MANY EXCELLENT.SHOTS OF CRICKET WERE INVENTED WHEN NO ONE NO ABOUT TWENTY TWENTY.......SO HOW CAN YOU SAY THAT THEY WILL NOT WORK IN THIS FORMAT................
MIX...TECHNICAL ANALYSIS..WITH MONEY MANAGEMENT....WE ALL CAN WIN ANY MARKET
harshit bhai..............ye batao......ki....kya koi batsman....out ho sakta hai agar woh....khud koi galti na kare......even....sachin tendulkar...kai baar khud ki galtiyon ke karan out ho gaye...wo bhi zero par.......90 se 100..ke beech bhi out ho gaye,...kai century..bhi maari, one day me double century bhi maari........kya aisa koi batsman hai jo kabhi out na hua ho.....to kya batting ki tips ya trics (means all shots)...kaam nahi karti.......ab baat bowling ki......aisa kaun sa bowler hai...jo kabhi bhi pita nahi.....aisi kaun se bowl hai jispar
chakka nahi pad sakta hai.....to kya bowling action aur line aur lenth sab bekaar hai.......
cricket is mind game.....so is trading.....technical analysis,may or may not work daily...
now i comes to your questions......
1. Technical analysis kaam karti hai ya nahi ,2. Agr karti hai tou kya intra day mein bhi karti hai ?------------
answer......yes for both......
explanation - bhai agar...KHALI KO BAT PAKDA DO AUR ZAHEER KHAN KE SAAMNE BHEJ DO....TO WOH KITNE RUN BANA...LEGA
AUR AGAR.. SEHWAAG KO BHEJO.....TO WO KITNE BANAYEGA.........WHAT IS DIFFERENCE,,,,,,IT IS KNOWLEDGE OF SHOTS.......EVEN KHALI CAN HIT THE BAAL HARDER THAN SEHWAAG,BUT HE DO NOT NO WHICH SHOT TO PLAY.........
SO IN TRADING......IF YOU DO NOT NO ABC OF TECHNICAL ANALYAIS....THEN YOU WILL SURELY BE A LOOSER........BUT IF YOU KNOW...EVEN USE OF MOVING AVERAGES.....THEN YOU CAN EARN SOME THING..(MAY BE VERY TINY)IN MARKET OR YOU CAN PROTECT YOUR CAPITAL.............NOW LIKE ABOVE EXAMPLE...YOUR EARNING DEPENDS UPON YOUR MIND,,AND YOUR KNOWLEDGE OF TECHNICAL ANALISIS.....
DAY TRADING IS NOTHING BUT A FARM OF TRADING.....LIKE SWING TRADING OR POSITIONAL TRADING.....THE DIFFERENCE IS ONLY THAT MANY TRADER PREFER LOWER TIMEFRAMES IN DAY TRADING..........SO TECHNICAL ANALYSIS WORK HERE TOO
NOW ASSUME DAY TRADING AS 20-20..FORMAT OF CRICKET......MANY EXCELLENT.SHOTS OF CRICKET WERE INVENTED WHEN NO ONE NO ABOUT TWENTY TWENTY.......SO HOW CAN YOU SAY THAT THEY WILL NOT WORK IN THIS FORMAT................
MIX...TECHNICAL ANALYSIS..WITH MONEY MANAGEMENT....WE ALL CAN WIN ANY MARKET
Last edited:
Similar threads
-
-
-
ICICI Prudentation floating interest fund generating negative returns over last 3 months
- Started by tondudaa
- Replies: 0
-
-
Historical data for Intraday Index Futures & Options for last three years
- Started by ravindraprasad
- Replies: 2