Czar,since you have mentioned my name in your PM:
I have quoted all your messages of this thread.... I did not leave any message...
Visiting renu's thread where she was posting some live threads today (what I usually do in NF Trading thread)..
First I agree with your question abt the indicator she's using - if i was online today during trading hours, even I would have asked her the same...
But when she did not reply, (can be for any reason - maybe she was busy with her trades as it was peak time 2:15pm+, or maybe she wanted to give u reply after EOD)...
then, as u admit, other guys (devangan & pantar) came & started posting something timepass messages
Devangan also made fun of her spelling mistakes - ok, it's common with her & she has taking it on her stride over the years - but anyone would get pissed out with SAME leg-pulling during trading hours & that too, during peak time when she was already in a losing position....
Comeon guys, if you don't consider yourself as robots & want some occasional humour, atleast don't get personal with jokes during trading hours - such that the receiving person is COMPELLED to answer to silly jokes...
Look from her view-point....
Her next reply was expected & was due to provocation ( i feel).... she felt that you all are attacking her in a group & she vowed not to post in forum again, in anger....
You both apologised, but look at the reason provided -
Renuji
Please Do not get angry , Actually kya hai subah se hi khaali bethe hai . aaj kuch trade hi naahi kara , initially due to broker software than due to boring market , to traderji ki new post search ka rahe the , or aapke thread me baar baar posting ho rahi thi vo bhi trading to phir bas aise hi ....
Please do not get angry we respect u as much we do for ashish da and saint
vo to bas aise hi aaj market to hasne de naahi raha socha yaha par hi thoda haas le
Devan
Devangan, since you are also an intraday scapler/swing trader, I hope you would realise that such posts would obviously distract another person who is making an attempt to share live trades....
Prasadam earlier wrote in this thread that this forum will be left only for flow trades if other methods are not discussed/shared live....
Will such exchange of jokes DURING PEAK TRADING TIME give any encouragement to the other person who is seriously engrossed in trading & not the correct time to joke around - just because u r free of any trading position!!!
I know that Renu has a history of joking around, but i seldom find her jokes during trading hours.... Also, I guess, for joking, both parties should be in THAT mood..... Be a little considerate.... If you expect not to be a paid robot here, atleast let others do their work -
As an outsider, all I see & feel that Renu was sharing her trades/method in her own thread - questions about method should always be taken in right spirit, but personal jokes (w/o the other party willing, and that too during peak trading hour) is never acceptable by any serious trader...
Quoting czar's post in some other thread, and not addressed to Renu, but in the spirit of discussion....
Not everyone here is for teaching & preaching, Its open for discussion & debates but do you expect everyone to open their method for every one ??? That also on demand !
This message by czar was the real heart-burner (atleast for me, if I had received the same)
sorry to ever bother you, I used to do in pity... since you talk to yourselve.... mostly boasting for no reason
Devangan, for you it might be a "minor" reason, but see from the other side too....
I read several messages in forum over weekend mentioning the process where some guys form a group & attack the thread initiator forcing him/her to stop posting.....
Though your intentions were not this (I can vouch this for sure), but apparently the recipient felt the same attack....
Renu is not some hanumanji (other member of this forum with whom u had some debate) who is an unreasonable tipster of this forum... she's been here since long time and is respected for her trading style too... May a times, she has helped me develop some trading strategies (especially gap ones) during my initial days in the forum..... But then respect should not be only in words - in deed too...
otherwise how would one stand apart from Nikhil who sent that senseless/baseless PM to many members, even though he says he has respect for Asish Da....
Ultimately, it's the SUper-Mod who also feels & states that all this amounts to dis-respect & insult to other members....
If czar considers me as a friend, then he should understand that my post was simply to question his folly decision to continue posting/provoking in her thread inspite of receiving first warning. If a friend is going wrong, one should be able to correct him...
I really don't know how hindi language came over here (initially even i was shocked to know that use of hindi language is reason for czar to be warned) but on visiting renu's thread, i came to know it was not language but content, as Traderji also clarified....
Czar:
Arre L2T dont write in hindi, TJ considers it bad language...
Now look at the result of getting too personal with same-repeated jokes (about spellings & about trading strategy) that too during peak trade time...
even renu is upset & is not willing to continue posting in this forum....
I feel that enemy of forum does not lie outside but within ourselves
If we don't consider the other person to be a serious contributor of the forum & actually express such opinion in this public forum, then it would not require a third outsider to create rift between two persons....
Simply barge in a thread form of a group, attack the thread initiator with personal remarks (especially when the time is not appropriate), post some Timepass messages, and then force him/her to quit the forum....
Voila - we have a "nikhil" inside us....
