Dear All,
Just yesterday I was thinking about the same subject when I read Creditviolet's post on 38 steps of trading. I sincerely believe that success rate of newbies like me can be improved by seniors sharing their knowledge with us. Its not possible for everyone to work in a trading house and the forum is a great way of alleviating the handicap.
Agreed, some of us will look for the short cut and try to use the strategies without doing their homework, but as someone has rightly said in one of the threads that your trading strategy should suit your personality because this is not an exact science.
What I suggest is people share their experiences instead of (or along with) their trading methods. Pick any (or couple) of their trades in a day and tell us how they actually went about doing that trade. What was going on in their minds when they did that trade. Try to write down their thoughts. What trend indicators? What oscillators? What fundamentals? How did the sensex movement affect their trading decision? TA charts and so on....
Secondly. donot group it all in a single thread. Lets have a thread for each company. For eg. if you want to share your trading experience of buying ZEE then start a thread which says "Trading Experience - Zee Tele" and then if any other member wants to share an experience of trading zee, he would reply in the same thread (use search functionality of the forum) or traderji can have a different title head for this in the main page. This way, I hope we would have company wise analysis from various people over a period of time.
Suggestions/Criticism most welcome.
My two cents!
Nihar