Finvasia

CougarTrader

Well-Known Member
finvasia is just like a seperate exchange , sell and buy is being executed at different values than the Exchages...
Chart high low also different than the Exchanges... looks like they are buying and selling with different values from clients and poketing the amount....
Don't spread baseless rumors! Order pooling is not allowed in India and strictly prohibited for any agency. If you have facts please feel free to walk up to the Exchange or SEBI. Complaining in Traderji won't help anyone.

Exchanges feed data (about 0.5 to 1 Gbps) - everyone receives and transmits a subset of it as per their server and data processing capabilities (generally outsourced to another vendor) - thus all charts won't be same. If you want good charts, subscribe to an Exchange authorized data-feed vendor separately. The disparity of OHLC that you are talking about can be reduced but never be eliminated. And it is not a sign that the Broker is doing something illegal. Other Broker's in-house tools have similar charting issues, often much bigger issues like OMS glitches, etc.

Order placing from Finvasia NOW or NEST is not a problem at all. Yes Scalpert needs a revamp but that comes with a price - nothing is free. But astonishingly they have kept free Brokerage + Clearing Charges, and they are the only one to do that.

Either go to ShareKhan's TradeTiger if you want in-house TA tools but Trading cost would be higher. Or get yourself a Licensed Trading Software, subscribe to a Data vendor and use Finvasia NOW or NEST for Order placing to keep Trading cost low.

However, it is absolutely absurd to claim that since charts on Broker's trading platform does not match with whatever that you are comparing to, implies that, the Broker is doing Order pooling.
 
Don't spread baseless rumors! Order pooling is not allowed in India and strictly prohibited for any agency. If you have facts please feel free to walk up to the Exchange or SEBI. Complaining in Traderji won't help anyone.

Exchanges feed data (about 0.5 to 1 Gbps) - everyone receives and transmits a subset of it as per their server and data processing capabilities (generally outsourced to another vendor) - thus all charts won't be same. If you want good charts, subscribe to an Exchange authorized data-feed vendor separately. The disparity of OHLC that you are talking about can be reduced but never be eliminated. And it is not a sign that the Broker is doing something illegal. Other Broker's in-house tools have similar charting issues, often much bigger issues like OMS glitches, etc.

Order placing from Finvasia NOW or NEST is not a problem at all. Yes Scalpert needs a revamp but that comes with a price - nothing is free. But astonishingly they have kept free Brokerage + Clearing Charges, and they are the only one to do that.

Either go to ShareKhan's TradeTiger if you want in-house TA tools but Trading cost would be higher. Or get yourself a Licensed Trading Software, subscribe to a Data vendor and use Finvasia NOW or NEST for Order placing to keep Trading cost low.

However, it is absolutely absurd to claim that since charts on Broker's trading platform does not match with whatever that you are comparing to, implies that, the Broker is doing Order pooling.
 
Don't spread baseless rumors! Order pooling is not allowed in India and strictly prohibited for any agency. If you have facts please feel free to walk up to the Exchange or SEBI. Complaining in Traderji won't help anyone.

Exchanges feed data (about 0.5 to 1 Gbps) - everyone receives and transmits a subset of it as per their server and data processing capabilities (generally outsourced to another vendor) - thus all charts won't be same. If you want good charts, subscribe to an Exchange authorized data-feed vendor separately. The disparity of OHLC that you are talking about can be reduced but never be eliminated. And it is not a sign that the Broker is doing something illegal. Other Broker's in-house tools have similar charting issues, often much bigger issues like OMS glitches, etc.

Order placing from Finvasia NOW or NEST is not a problem at all. Yes Scalpert needs a revamp but that comes with a price - nothing is free. But astonishingly they have kept free Brokerage + Clearing Charges, and they are the only one to do that.

Either go to ShareKhan's TradeTiger if you want in-house TA tools but Trading cost would be higher. Or get yourself a Licensed Trading Software, subscribe to a Data vendor and use Finvasia NOW or NEST for Order placing to keep Trading cost low.

However, it is absolutely absurd to claim that since charts on Broker's trading platform does not match with whatever that you are comparing to, implies that, the Broker is doing Order pooling.
crude.png
 
now Crude values are 3995 not only in chart in tic values also and today till now Crude not croosed above 3995 from 9:15 AM ... and see the chart...
What are you doing man?
Shouting in the official thread and not getting your facts right :shifty:
You are looking at two different scrips (CRUDEOIL MINI and CRUDEOIL MAIN) and different expires – 21 OCT and 19 NOV
Here screenshot of both (from official MCX website):

crudeoilM (19 Nov).png crudeoilM (21oct).png

The price was above 3995, which is why it got executed in Finvasia. Don’t blame a broker like that. Please get your facts straight from the next time.
 
Don't spread baseless rumors! Order pooling is not allowed in India and strictly prohibited for any agency. If you have facts please feel free to walk up to the Exchange or SEBI. Complaining in Traderji won't help anyone.

Exchanges feed data (about 0.5 to 1 Gbps) - everyone receives and transmits a subset of it as per their server and data processing capabilities (generally outsourced to another vendor) - thus all charts won't be same. If you want good charts, subscribe to an Exchange authorized data-feed vendor separately. The disparity of OHLC that you are talking about can be reduced but never be eliminated. And it is not a sign that the Broker is doing something illegal. Other Broker's in-house tools have similar charting issues, often much bigger issues like OMS glitches, etc.

Order placing from Finvasia NOW or NEST is not a problem at all. Yes Scalpert needs a revamp but that comes with a price - nothing is free. But astonishingly they have kept free Brokerage + Clearing Charges, and they are the only one to do that.

Either go to ShareKhan's TradeTiger if you want in-house TA tools but Trading cost would be higher. Or get yourself a Licensed Trading Software, subscribe to a Data vendor and use Finvasia NOW or NEST for Order placing to keep Trading cost low.

However, it is absolutely absurd to claim that since charts on Broker's trading platform does not match with whatever that you are comparing to, implies that, the Broker is doing Order pooling.
if there is mismatch in charts any body can understand... but trade should not be executed 4 to 5 points (crude ) away from the live price... as that order has to go to exchange and get it conformed and executed at the live price at that time .... but trade also being executed at different value..(if one point means it can be acceptable)... why i m putting here some body who is trading innocently market orders like me shall take care...
 
What are you doing man?
Shouting in the official thread and not getting your facts right :shifty:
You are looking at two different scrips (CRUDEOIL MINI and CRUDEOIL MAIN) and different expires – 21 OCT and 19 NOV
Here screenshot of both (from official MCX website):

View attachment 37798 View attachment 37799

The price was above 3995, which is why it got executed in Finvasia. Don’t blame a broker like that. Please get your facts straight from the next time.
ok sorry.... let me check.....