Finvasia

[raja4204]

@brokenbull bro how was BTST in finvasia now , can i sell any share in second day without any hiccups , please share your experience

 

[brokenbull]

@brokenbull bro how was BTST in finvasia now , can i sell any share in second day without any hiccups , please share your experience

1) In Finvasia -90% of the time previous day's CNC buy scrip shows up Next day by 8.30am.(for BTST T1) .
2) rarely if it does not show in watchlist/holdings at 9.15am , you want to sell badly, contact via chat, at the worst your previous day purchase will show as T1 in holdings or watch list by 2-2.30pm.
3) If you are non POA , you can not place BTST cnc sell order during AMO. but you can at 9.00-9.07am , CDSL pop out works. (but no blanket authorisation like zerodha)
so you can place CNC BTST sell eiether during 9-9.06 am or after 9.15am .( During pre market 9-07am (with in 7 mins) I have placed 6 orders one day each with Tpin+otp .)
another thing each scrip, each quantity you have to authorise via cdsl pop out TPIN+otp.
4) I took a trading break from both Zerodha & Finvasia since March 26th.,
whole april no trade. Just few days ago I put capital back in to zerodha as I wanted to trade only overnight BTST & not intraday .
5) however some intra day trade goes through even if I put higher profit target . ( have to pay comission+gst in zerodha ) . Today I sold yesterdays purchase of Voltas. Today purchase at the exact bottom Jindalsteel ,Zeel, India cements etc got sold in intraday itself. since Iam laddering in small lots I bought manyy scrips in Zerodha today during 3.10-3.29pm (today I placed 35 small MIS buy orders at rock bottom s2>s3 during amo..I got lucky in 5-6 scrips.
6. I may re start Finvasia may be end May only for intraday small profit trades.
I want to see how my "no intraday" trading at zerodha as much as possible (higher profit target experiment ),
for over night I prefer zerodha.( zerodha delivery trade no commision -all other terms same as finvasia. except zerodha cdsl charge 12+gst compared to finvasia's 9+gst/scrip)

 

[Finvasia]

Dear TJ Members!
We are glad to inform you that we have extended our payout hours. From 17/05/2021, you will be able to place withdrawal requests between 8:30AM - 5:00PM from Monday to Friday (excluding holidays) and receive the payout on the same day.

 

[Infooo]

Start taking Payout request till 330 PM instead of 12 PM cut off.. specially when you have such untrustworthy application, it's tough to rely on you with money

Thanks for listening to us and extension in payout timing

 

[brokenbull]

Dear TJ Members!
We are glad to inform you that we have extended our payout hours. From 17/05/2021, you will be able to place withdrawal requests between 8:30AM - 5:00PM from Monday to Friday (excluding holidays) and receive the payout on the same day.

View attachment 46039

Badly needed fix in Shoonya Android App.
1)Automatic Trade execution notice in shoonya android app (mostly appears in left corner of the phone. You can see how it works in Zerodha android app). Shoonya dessktop exe does give sound on trade execution.But it hogs bandwidth & if we run EXE along with Trading view chart & another broker (say KITE) even in differewnt browsers , all crashes. So I find shoonya android app the best with out straining the laptop
2) when you are pushing announcements , it shows up in shoonya android app .
Why your development team can not figure out automatic trade execution notification in shoonya android app ?

 

[raja4204]

1) In Finvasia -90% of the time previous day's CNC buy scrip shows up Next day by 8.30am.(for BTST T1) .
2) rarely if it does not show in watchlist/holdings at 9.15am , you want to sell badly, contact via chat, at the worst your previous day purchase will show as T1 in holdings or watch list by 2-2.30pm.
3) If you are non POA , you can not place BTST cnc sell order during AMO. but you can at 9.00-9.07am , CDSL pop out works. (but no blanket authorisation like zerodha)
so you can place CNC BTST sell eiether during 9-9.06 am or after 9.15am .( During pre market 9-07am (with in 7 mins) I have placed 6 orders one day each with Tpin+otp .)
another thing each scrip, each quantity you have to authorise via cdsl pop out TPIN+otp.
4) I took a trading break from both Zerodha & Finvasia since March 26th.,
whole april no trade. Just few days ago I put capital back in to zerodha as I wanted to trade only overnight BTST & not intraday .
5) however some intra day trade goes through even if I put higher profit target . ( have to pay comission+gst in zerodha ) . Today I sold yesterdays purchase of Voltas. Today purchase at the exact bottom Jindalsteel ,Zeel, India cements etc got sold in intraday itself. since Iam laddering in small lots I bought manyy scrips in Zerodha today during 3.10-3.29pm (today I placed 35 small MIS buy orders at rock bottom s2>s3 during amo..I got lucky in 5-6 scrips.
6. I may re start Finvasia may be end May only for intraday small profit trades.
I want to see how my "no intraday" trading at zerodha as much as possible (higher profit target experiment ),
for over night I prefer zerodha.( zerodha delivery trade no commision -all other terms same as finvasia. except zerodha cdsl charge 12+gst compared to finvasia's 9+gst/scrip)

thanks bro for taking your time and sharing your experience

 

[newtrader101]

BO can be modified now.

 

[iTrade]

Can someone tell me stability of shoonya desktop app? Not interested in charting but fast order processing? Also does the app work fine if u keep it open entire market time?

 

[brokenbull]

thanks bro for taking your time and sharing your experience

If your capital is light (say 5-7 lakhs ₹) , you want to mainly do intraday stock & occasionally delivery trade (if forced or by design or accumulating in instalments in a down trend )-Finvasia is best. No commisions for intraday or delivery stock trades also for futures & options.
BTST next day AM/PM is a not a problem 99% of the time .(with or with out POA)
Not to mention with the same capital you can dabble in comodities also (no separate balance)

 

[brokenbull]

Can someone tell me stability of shoonya desktop app? Not interested in charting but fast order processing? Also does the app work fine if u keep it open entire market time?

1) depends on your computer's "computing power "(RAM ) + internet strength etc & also depends on what else you will be running along with shoonya desk top !
2) opening charts (more than 1 ) surely will crash the system . Can run whole day but you may need to close & re start 1 or 2 time .many time chart bar/prices wont update but prices will be changing in the shoonya watch list.
3) if the order is placed successfully , then it is in NSE/MCX web site in micro seconds. then it will execute as per your limit/market order instructions.
sometimes updated as "traded" takes a few extra seconds in shoonya (more so in android app). If Iam in doubt (order traded or not ) , I hit "edit" on a pending order- then it sheepishly says "your order already traded"
3) also how hungry is your other charting system is also a factor.
4) I like desktop as it gives execution sounds . but running Desk top (with out touching the chart)+ 1 browser Trading view chart+ different browser Zerodha kite volume bar chart+ with volume profile not stable continously.( My AMD Ryzen 3 -4GB RAM-1TB laptop has 1 free slot but still I have not added another 8gb stick. so my laptop is kind of weak with only4 gb ram)
Because of these issues
5) I KEEP TRADING VIEW CHARTS + manage TRADES IN FINVASIA via ANDROID APP ONLY + trades in ZERODHA ALSO VIA APP ONLY .
But after 2.45 pm close trading view charts & keep zerodha kite chart only towards closing time as too many tasks like
1)close pending un excuted MIS orders + 2)closing executed MIS orders for a profit /scratch/small loss
3)convert MIS buy's to to CNC for possible BTST 4) selectively CNC fresh buy small quantity of missed stocks during 3.15-3.29pm for BTST