I really do not want to get into the middle of this dispute. Please stop trolling his charts. His drawings do have a basis. Al Brooks in his book "Trading Ranges" stated that you can draw the lines at the end of the bar or at the body and you can start at the opening of the first bar and then you can draw it to the high of the last bar etc. He basically meant all possibilities are valid. Regarding that line which passed through a green candle and a subsequent red candle bodies, it is not wrong. I will give two reasons. If you look at a higher time frame, an outlier pair of consecutive, overlapping red and green candles becomes a tail. So, he just drew across the tail. The other reason is that those candles just crossed the line which he drew and immediately pulled back. This is a sign which tells that the line he drew was respected.
Guys, please note that the purpose of those drawings is to understand market behavior. Learning geometry is not our goal here.
Please do not think I am taking sides here. I read those Al Brooks books and am merely expressing my thoughts based on what is mentioned in those books.
Moreover, please do not fight or troll. If you did not like something related to analysis, please ignore. But if somebody is talking about politics etc then report to the admins. This approach works well for trading discussion and our trading health too.