Day Traders Lounge.

AJK

Well-Known Member
Only in India we think its OK for police to use brutal force. Yes there could be some stone pelters hidden in library and police is hitting them. But it does prove we are not even a developing nation... for same reason, police in India are feared and we don’t feel secured in their presence. May be “angrez chale gaye, police brutality chhod gaye”

Edit: no comment on any protest, purely on police use of extra force. Be it recent case or any other in India. We have more cases on extra judicial killing by police than any other democracies
One simple question. Imagine one has been instructed by his father to bring up children obedient for the sake of home and for the sake of their future. Imagine the son throws stone at father when he insists him to be obedient to house' policies. What one father should do in this situation? Let alone if it was someone else's child who has been handed over to be cared by you... Police is also humans. If you had your career as a police, now you'd have been telling the other ways around.
 

siddhant4u

Well-Unknown Member
One simple question. Imagine one has been instructed by his father to bring up children obedient for the sake of home and for the sake of their future. Imagine the son throws stone at father when he insists him to be obedient to house' policies. What one father should do in this situation? Let alone if it was someone else's child who has been handed over to be cared by you... Police is also humans. If you had your career as a police, now you'd have been telling the other ways around.
In civilised developed countries even parents are not allowed to smack their children
 

siddhant4u

Well-Unknown Member
One simple question. Imagine one has been instructed by his father to bring up children obedient for the sake of home and for the sake of their future. Imagine the son throws stone at father when he insists him to be obedient to house' policies. What one father should do in this situation? Let alone if it was someone else's child who has been handed over to be cared by you... Police is also humans. If you had your career as a police, now you'd have been telling the other ways around.
We have courts for handing out punishment
 

siddhant4u

Well-Unknown Member
Also police personnel are for protection of civilians and public property, doesn't matter if it's from highly educated or less educated.
consider the incident happened some years back in Nagpur. People from one caste were waiting to meet then CM Sharad Pawar for hours in hot weather. He promised he was coming, later he flew back to Mumbai without meeting the people who were sitting on peaceful protest. People got agitated, police started hitting with baton and result was stampede and 114 got killed. (search Gowari incident)

Now tell me police were not brutal. All you are focused on one incident of Jamila Protest, look at police brutality in all cases and make judgement.

Today you say, police should use brute force because they are human, what about other innocents who get caught between miscreant and police fight, they are human too, so they should start hitting police now (based on your logic).

Besides, law does not give police any rights to use brute force. unless we want to live in lawless country. Indians in general (higher proportion) are uncivilised (eve-teasing, spitting, hitting, fighting, mob killing.. )

disclaimer: I don't belong to Gowari caste, nor was part of any protest.
 

AJK

Well-Known Member
consider the incident happened some years back in Nagpur. People from one caste were waiting to meet then CM Sharad Pawar for hours in hot weather. He promised he was coming, later he flew back to Mumbai without meeting the people who were sitting on peaceful protest. People got agitated, police started hitting with baton and result was stampede and 114 got killed. (search Gowari incident)

Now tell me police were not brutal. All you are focused on one incident of Jamila Protest, look at police brutality in all cases and make judgement.

Today you say, police should use brute force because they are human, what about other innocents who get caught between miscreant and police fight, they are human too, so they should start hitting police now (based on your logic).

Besides, law does not give police any rights to use brute force. unless we want to live in lawless country. Indians in general (higher proportion) are uncivilised (eve-teasing, spitting, hitting, fighting, mob killing.. )

disclaimer: I don't belong to Gowari caste, nor was part of any protest.
What I'm saying is law and order should be there.. can courts come all the way to the crime scene and help the victims before the crime happens? What's the point if antisocials had done with their feast and relatives of victims waiting for courts' mercy for years? What stops antisocial thoughts from happening is this brutality of police at the right place.. Could the court or any of us help those girls recently? If the culprits are behind the bars now, its only because of this police intervention.. Public should have a fear to break the laws or do mischief, and that's only because of fear of police brutality, not from the fear of court punishment decades later...

And if police just stay calm during these events, then people would cry there's no law and order.
 

AJK

Well-Known Member
Maybe several millennia later, a new species, a baby of them, would ask his father; dad, what all these books say? were there humans long before us lived here? had they had super powers? atomic bomb? missiles? did they have flying machines? ancient science? wow!

Then dad would say; yes son, they were gods, devatas. They had many super powers, but they used it to kill each other. We cannot see them anymore, because they've become fossil fuel beneath our feet, underground... And we will use it to lighten our lives. And the cycle goes on....
 
Last edited: