best broker for intraday trading

#21
1) just checked SAS brokerage calculator. For intraday equities @₹9 max plan (or 0.01%) is indeed cheaper than Zerodha for intraday equities
2) But for equity delivery trade Zerodha is zero brokerage .SAS is ₹9+ gst(for one way)
3) Rather use Finvasia intraday is "free" . If forced to convert MIS to CNC due to under water but want to keep stock , still free delivery trade . Nowadays Finvasia does work ok for BTST (T1 CNC sell next day -with CDSL TPIN+otp).
Finvasia no a/c opening /AMC charges.
I think I paid ₹300 or so while a/c opening in Zerodha + quarterly around ₹75 amc charges I think ( SAS's ₹600 looks higher)
4) I do like Finvasia Desktop exe as it gives sound when order is traded . But opening Finvasia EXE, Trading view in 1 browser & zerodha kite in another browser .....crashes after some time. so no finvasia exe. only finvasia android app. all trading decisions are made in trading view charts & executed in the respective android app (or alter existing AMO orders placed at 8am )
5) Zerodha has 3 million customers I think . Even if 1 million customers keep ₹1 lakh cash with zerodha .. conservatively ₹1 billion of customer cash.
Healthy cushion to keep my/your ₹1or 2 million with zerodha & sleep sound at night. (only market risk no broker risk)
SAS is offering Nest trader, which seems a big advantage. Shoonya is yet to settle down.

Edit : Nest too gives a beep on order execution.
 

kaly422000

Well-Known Member
#22
1) just checked SAS brokerage calculator. For intraday equities @₹9 max plan (or 0.01%) is indeed cheaper than Zerodha for intraday equities
2) But for equity delivery trade Zerodha is zero brokerage .SAS is ₹9+ gst(for one way)
3) Rather use Finvasia intraday is "free" . If forced to convert MIS to CNC due to under water but want to keep stock , still free delivery trade . Nowadays Finvasia does work ok for BTST (T1 CNC sell next day -with CDSL TPIN+otp).
Finvasia no a/c opening /AMC charges.
I think I paid ₹300 or so while a/c opening in Zerodha + quarterly around ₹75 amc charges I think ( SAS's ₹600 looks higher)
4) I do like Finvasia Desktop exe as it gives sound when order is traded . But opening Finvasia EXE, Trading view in 1 browser & zerodha kite in another browser .....crashes after some time. so no finvasia exe. only finvasia android app. all trading decisions are made in trading view charts & executed in the respective android app (or alter existing AMO orders placed at 8am )
5) Zerodha has 3 million customers I think . Even if 1 million customers keep ₹1 lakh cash with zerodha .. conservatively ₹1 billion of customer cash.
Healthy cushion to keep my/your ₹1or 2 million with zerodha & sleep sound at night. (only market risk no broker risk)
if u use finvasia web interface. did u test that it is crashing?
 
#23
if u use finvasia web interface. did u test that it is crashing?
i did not try. I used shoonya web sometimes during amo & then close it after placing the orders . I can not stare at nos blinking. I need visual chart based price .Shoonya desktop & web are useless for charts . if you change scip ,all chart settings goes off. so no use wasting time.
Either Zerodha KIte volume Bar chart+ Volume profile +CPR+ Pivots + VWAP /AVWAP or Trading view chart with my favourite 3 set up (free version)
I am not in to downloading data in excel or amibroker business.
 
#25
Well, get ready to be flooded with numerous broker recommendations. Different traders, different choices. Best way to find one is to research a lot and then try the ones that match your style. Nonetheless, here comes my recommendation- finvasia, because of its professional user-interface and fast execution. Plus there’s zero brokerage fees.
 

kaly422000

Well-Known Member
#26
i did not try. I used shoonya web sometimes during amo & then close it after placing the orders . I can not stare at nos blinking. I need visual chart based price .Shoonya desktop & web are useless for charts . if you change scip ,all chart settings goes off. so no use wasting time.
Either Zerodha KIte volume Bar chart+ Volume profile +CPR+ Pivots + VWAP /AVWAP or Trading view chart with my favourite 3 set up (free version)
I am not in to downloading data in excel or amibroker business.
if execution and placing order is ok with all type of trade(limit,market,sl-m etc) execution is ok, then ok for me as chart can be seen thru other brokers or trading view or may be amibroker. if u confirm that trade execution and order placement is ok in finvasia
 
#27
if execution and placing order is ok with all type of trade(limit,market,sl-m etc) execution is ok, then ok for me as chart can be seen thru other brokers or trading view or may be amibroker. if u confirm that trade execution and order placement is ok in finvasia
If your order is in the system, it will execute like any other broker. sometimes Traded notification takes a extra few seconds, In android app nio traded notification like zerodha .Cgart you can view in Trading view or zerodha kite. Only Finvasia android app I use most of the time
 

Similar threads

Zerodha – Open Paperless Account

Open online account with Zerodha. Free delivery trading and Max Rs 20 for Intraday, F&O, Currency and Commodity Trading. Intraday High leverage with MIS, CO and BO.

Name:Phone:
Email:City:
State:
Are you a day trader?