Search results

  1. V

    Upstox - RKSV - Trade in Rs 20 Max

    I thought Fyers was bad but Upstox is even worse. Tried opening an account, I couldn't get the OTP for some reason. Sent them an email, sent DM on Twitter. 4 working days gone, not even an acknowledgement.
  2. V

    FYERS

    I know I opted for imgur to keep it clean. Did not want to make it into a huge post, especially given that some people have been unhappy with my criticism of Fyers already :)
  3. V

    FYERS

    And here as I was thinking everything was working fine, I hit a big roadblock. The platform's span margin isn't robust at all. I had 19k in my account: and tried selling a 22700/22800 credit spread on BN. The margin calculator says I need 13646 margin: Opstra says 13.3k: I expected the...
  4. V

    FYERS

    This works. Thank you. Edit: Never mind. The UPI problem has been solved. Somehow ICICI UPI wasn't working. Tried Google pay and it works. Though the payment is kinda slow. Takes 20-30 seconds from Google Pay confirmation to Atom confirmation on Fyers.
  5. V

    FYERS

    Here's my experience in trading as a complete newbie on Fyers: 1. Adding money via UPI from ICICI somehow doesn't work. Tried couple of times but it failed. I don't know if the issue is ICICI UPI or Fyers payment gateway. I'll have to test this more to see where the issue lies exactly. Finally...
  6. V

    FYERS

    No they wouldn't. Fact is your platform technology is bad. And I'll give you an example of how and why the onboarding sucked: First, I got two emails containing login info. I complained about the first one. And 4 hrs later I got another email with login info. Don't tell me you send out two...
  7. V

    FYERS

    I received another email with login details. And now login works fine. Now I have another issue. I need to update the password before I can use the account. And I keep getting - Something went wrong. Please try again later. This has to be one of the worst account opening experiences yet.
  8. V

    FYERS

    Please do tell which service on Google/Facebook takes time to activate?
  9. V

    FYERS

    I somehow got through the registration phase and honestly the experience has not been smooth. Now I received the client id and password email 2 hrs back. and I can't login; I get an error "User doesn't exist". Support tells me that I can login after 12am or before market hours. And the email...
  10. V

    FYERS

    Yesterday I tried opening an account with Fyers. And I can see why Zerodha attracts so many people. Zerodha's account opening and onboarding is smooth. I can upload documents and complete most of the procedures quickly. There is minimal interaction required. Fyers website on the other hand is...
  11. V

    Differences in screener results?

    I am trying to look at some screeners for taking long term positions. When I run the same query on: https://www.screener.in/ and https://www.edelweiss.in/oyo/equity/user/screener I get vastly different results. For example, ROE > 20 and Profit Growth > 15 shows lot of differences. Any...
  12. V

    Discount Broker Comparison

    Curious, what does this mean? Btw, anyone has ideas about mobile trading clients? I see there is a NOW Mobile version too. anyone tried that?
  13. V

    Discount Broker Comparison

    NRML and MIS seems to be a strange feature coming out of risk management by Indian brokers. I had IB abroad and there aren't any MIS/NRML/CNC orders etc - orders are just orders.
  14. V

    Broker for trading Stock Options

    I have looked at some of the comparisons and it seems trading stock options in India is very costly. A minimum charge of 5k for 1 crore in turnover. So, I am wondering which is the best of these brokers? Any ideas, guys.
  15. V

    What are the details to look for in annual reports of Tata Elxsi, Wimplast and Eclerx

    Re: What are the details to look for in annual reports of Tata Elxsi, Wimplast and Ec I normally don't post on TJ as people tend to think I am too condescending so take, what I am going to say, as you may. Correct me if I am wrong but from the first post I understood that you have built a...
  16. V

    Bonds ETF?

    Yea, that could be better. Just how do I go about doing that. Are they available with brokers like Sharekhan/IIFL? Also any tips where can I start learning the fundamental analysis so as to start in this field? Cause it really sounds like easy money (if they are easier than stocks :D)
  17. V

    Bonds ETF?

    Anyone help me with this.
  18. V

    Bonds ETF?

    Fees and liquidity availability. I am building my own portfolio which will be actively managed and cant wait sitting on my hands - for MFs to complete their due process and get my money (and annoying sales people calling - Its a good option, Sir, please dont withdraw money etc). ETFs as opposed...
  19. V

    Bonds ETF?

    But I dont want MF. I am looking for ETFs. Anyone?
  20. V

    Bonds ETF?

    So I am looking to invest in some ETFs. Now I can see all kinds of ETFs but not bonds. I found one LiquidBees from Goldman on NSE but the data is not usable. All open/closes are near 1000 and completely disregard any coupon payments. So if anyone knows where I can find some bond ETFs and daily...