Recent content by Creep

  1. C

    FYERS

    Zerodha and 5paisa are now 0 for futures and options Upstox is Rs 20/crore for futures and Rs 500/crore on options Samco is Rs 25/crore for futures and Rs 750/crore on options Fyers is Rs 40/crore for futures and Rs 900/crore on options Are you referring to the above brokers or someone else...
  2. C

    Zerodha - Number One Discount Broker in India

    Upstox, fyers, samco etc where I have accounts all charge quite a bit as clearing charge. 5paisa was 0, figured out yesterday from my friends.
  3. C

    Comparison of clearing charges between discount brokers

    I had never thought that clearing charges are going to be different across brokers. But apparently there seems to be a big difference. I am listing out the charges with some of the brokers me and my friends use. Zerodha and 5paisa are now 0 for futures and options Upstox is Rs 20/crore for...
  4. C

    FYERS

    https://zerodha.com/z-connect/zerodha/zero-clearing-charges-from-22nd-march-for-equity-fo your clearing charges are quite high. Will you reduce it. The cost savings for an active intraday trader in terms of clearing charges will be quite high. Posting on this thread because Fyers team seems to...
  5. C

    Zerodha - Number One Discount Broker in India

    Clearing charges become 0 https://zerodha.com/z-connect/zerodha/zero-clearing-charges-from-22nd-march-for-equity-fo , now to see if other discount brokers follow
  6. C

    Future of Discount Brokers

    India is 25 years behind the US in terms of stock markets, brokers, trading and everything else. I think brokers in India have to first get more people to trade before they look at making money from these value added services. Most of the discount brokers have less than 30000 active clients...
  7. C

    FYERS

    Hi Tejas, you are losing all my respect buddy. Very comfortably you ignored my example and decided to quote yours without any thought/research. 1. If expense ratio for direct is 1.2 and regular is 2.5. That means I pay 1.3% extra. This is debited end of everyday and not end of a year. So if...
  8. C

    FYERS

    Are you serious about trail commissions, quite disappointing to hear you say this. I thought you were one of the transparent kind of brokers with your other answers. DSP Tax saver regular is 2.5 expense ratio and direct is 1.2. So 1.3% annualized is reduced from the NAV daily additionally for...
  9. C

    FYERS

    Clearing fees is Rs 20 and Rs 200 with Zerodha, Rs 20 and Rs 500 with Upstox. With you it will be Rs 50 and Rs 900 . So between 2 to 3 times. Why is DP charges so much higher? 25 is definitely the highest among all discount brokers isn't it? Check out TPs excel sheet. Also when will BSE and...
  10. C

    Zerodha - Number One Discount Broker in India

    Why is one of my holding not showing in Kite? It is showing on Q?
  11. C

    FYERS

    I was checking your website now, your transaction charges are much much higher than others. I am reading it correctly, Rs 100/crore for futures and Rs 900/crore on options premium? That is 2 to 3 times more than all discount brokers? Also DP charges are double to what...
  12. C

    Discount Broker Comparison

    Okay boys, for all of those who used to call me skeptical, reality check... Unicorn has lost 24 Crores is 2011-12, they haven't filed their returns yet for 2012, so they are definitely hiding something, my bet is they are going down and along with client funds... Coming to discount brokerages...
  13. C

    Discount Broker Comparison

    Good job BPR, anyways, your calculator made me curios to see what could be the google trend for these brokers, basically the number of times people are searching for these brokers on google, a good indication of understanding the size. http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=3010zzn&s=8#.U0uJ1vmSxxw...
  14. C

    Discount Broker Comparison

    Do let us know if you end up making money after saving all those costs.. :) .. Low costs is not necessarily good, especially the ones where you pay a monthly upfront fees.. I have seen a lot of my friends blow up their accounts in a hurry, just with the idea that since the brokerage is already...
  15. C

    Zerodha - Number One Discount Broker in India

    :) , 6.47pm you guys announce beta of new office, 6.51 the other broker announces.. Very nice, atleast all of you are not fighting out only based on pricing..