Discount Broker Comparison

I recently had an interaction with Bezel
1) the guy did not reply to all my common queries (which were also sent to other discount brokers and they replied to all)
2) my last email to them remains unanswered (after nearly 15 days)
3) I asked for demo through their toll free number, but the experience was not good

4) there is another thread on some issue with bezel
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/46182-bezel-security-review-feedback.html

I had a similar experience with Bezel.. I had to ultimately open my account with Zerodha

@ Trader Ravi, Soft trader, poortrader and others,

any broker who allows to Hold shares at MARGIN in client beneficial account / pool account ? t + 5 pay out or square off.

Hi saakk

Can you chk this post

http://www.traderji.com/brokers-tra...iscount-broker-comparision-11.html#post865642

astha trade review by mohideen171
Indexing this here for my future reference.
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/90036-asthashare.html#post870903

Some other review links

http://www.traderji.com/brokers-tra...apest-equity-commodity-broker.html#post870529
http://www.traderji.com/brokers-tra...apest-equity-commodity-broker.html#post870516

Guys tell me when(month and year) each of these brokers started their online broking business?
I will use this data for reliability indicator for the broker.

@bpr
very good job,when i wanted to open an account i had hard time looking for info and comparison,you have made it easy for many newcomers thanks.
BTW I am unable to download your excel sheet,can you pls upload latest file from any other site you can use google doc,mediafire,dropbox etc.

Any Idea about ACTION ? 1 PAISE / ORDER (but, a big bug is the deposit of money)

https://www.actionfin.com/Index.aspx

deposit money red flag

re uploaded 1.7 version
The link will be valid for 90 days
http://wikisend.com/download/424602/Discount Broker Charges Comparison v1.7.xlsx

Will post updated version soon do not have time ...