Your suggestions please!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Traderji

Super Moderator
#11
pkjha30 said:
Hi

Following are the wishlist for revamped forum

1. Historical data for BSE and NSE
2. EOD data
3. Streaming data
4. Fundamentals, financials and various indicators of Listed Companies
5. A recommendations area for investment
6. Trends and research reports
7. A tight reorganisation of topics

It could be a paid service and most members would welcome it.

Thanks
Hello pkjha30,

Traderji.com falls in the perview of a free and open discussion forum to exchange ideas and information. We will consider your recommendations.
 
#12
Hi,
I do agree with Mr.pkjha30, U could revamp the site with

1. Historical data for BSE and NSE
2. EOD data
Members in the fourum are always looking for data source, It would be nice if its provided here with the necessary charges.

Recomendations would also be good for many who dont know how to analyse, its a sticky issue since i know what it feels to give advice.But if it is done it has to be done
with good technical analysis proper stoplosses which have to be followed up till close of position or reversing of position.It should be paid service.

Regards
prashanth
 

pkjha30

Well-Known Member
#13
Dear Traderji

If it is going to be a subscription based service views and comments will have to be backed up by solid data and research.

I have one more suggestion

There could be stock specific discussion and stock prices at the time of post coud be noted along with the post.It would help us in judging reliability of the posts and also reduce the misuse of the forum

Members are posting charts on the forum for advice and technical analysis.I suggest that to see a breakout probably three or six monthe charts wpold be required.If a seperate section for such charts could be made where members could upload charts directly for the benefit of others.
Thanks
 
#14
Hi Traderji,

It is great effort to maintain such a forum, which teaches us fishing in the ocean of stock market, My hearty thanks to Traderji and our great fishermen who share their knowledge, experience, try to guide and encourage new fellow members like me to make a smooth journey in to the stock market.

Upgrading is a very good idea by which we keep our self-synchronized with time.

Traderji I would request you to keep most in this forum free by which it would encourage many curious young and experienced traders to take part in the discussions.

Here are few of my suggestions
1. In the forum adding Date to the thread / thread starter would be useful.
2. If there is an option to sort with new thread or last post will be useful.
3. If New post and New topics since you last visited are two different links would be better.
4. A separate link to paid service can also be added.

Thanks for the opportunity :cool:
Let Traderji be the best forum for Indian stock market. :) :) :)
 
#15
Hi all,

Yes this is an intelligent superb site.

My request is that to start a virtual account / game for each member

where he can transect stocks and judge his own abilities over share market.

Some sort of puzzles or questions can also be started for new bees.

thanks.

sharv.
 
#16
i think the people who give stock tips should be evaluated whether by admin or by members themselves so that man can be seperated from boys.ther should be seperate section where not everybody should be allowed to post without any rationale
 

vince

Active Member
#17
I feel that all tips whether posted in this forum or elsewhere should be taken with an automatic disclaimer of

"Trade at your own risk , the person /firm issuing these tips is not responsible for any losses incurred".
There have been glaring instances of tips issued by even leading brokerage houses going horribly wrong. Technical analysis is an art of probabilities and what the market may do in the future of course what it eventually does is an entirely different matter.
Take for instance the recent supposed head and shoulders pattern being formed by the sensex/nifty which almost all leading analysts were talking about and look at what the market did. It just rubbished all these theories and went on to make a new high.
As for the boys and men I feel this forum is to help the boys grow to men by meaningful and educative interaction with all members junior or senior. Trading is one of the few professions in which a person continuously evolves and learns with each passing day. The day a trader becomes complacent you can be sure he is going to go through another learning curve and the market is a great leveller and can reduce grown men to tears in no time.
I feel having any such sections would defeat the very purpose of this forum.
Trade Well
 
#18
this is a superb site. I have just one suggestion. While putting the date on the posts, instead of putting today and yesterday, if you pu the actual date like july 17,2005 it will help gratly because sometimes when I dont have time , i just copy paste the msgs to read it later. if the actual date is given, it will be of great help.
 
#19
Dear Traderji,

The upgradation is indeed great news though this is probably the most informative of all India sites.Nothing comes free so I am hopefull that other members /potential members will agree if some of the offerings came at a price but which enrich us in all respects.
This is my wishlist...
1.Make Traderji .com a site for educating blokes like us.I wonder how many of the forum members do understand Elliot and are able to aplly whilst trading.I see some of the questions being posted and I fear most guys are just into this without getting the full import of the hazards of investing or day trading.Traderji.com should become a one stop site for the greenhorns and also the likes of some of the very distinguished sr. members.

2.Introducing a segment which will track the Put-Call ratio,Open Interest major scrip wise along with a simple charts of the respective scrips or index.These would naturally include the index heavies as well as those maid cap movers.

3.Making a segment for only Daily recommendations which would be available by 9.45 am and refershed the next day with a new set of recomendations This does lead to a point already raised --about evaluating the contributors.
There are more butwould be very to see the above.

regards and Best Wishes

Soumitra
 

Traderji

Super Moderator
#20
vince said:
I feel that all tips whether posted in this forum or elsewhere should be taken with an automatic disclaimer of

"Trade at your own risk , the person /firm issuing these tips is not responsible for any losses incurred".
There have been glaring instances of tips issued by even leading brokerage houses going horribly wrong. Technical analysis is an art of probabilities and what the market may do in the future of course what it eventually does is an entirely different matter.
Take for instance the recent supposed head and shoulders pattern being formed by the sensex/nifty which almost all leading analysts were talking about and look at what the market did. It just rubbished all these theories and went on to make a new high.
As for the boys and men I feel this forum is to help the boys grow to men by meaningful and educative interaction with all members junior or senior. Trading is one of the few professions in which a person continuously evolves and learns with each passing day. The day a trader becomes complacent you can be sure he is going to go through another learning curve and the market is a great leveller and can reduce grown men to tears in no time.
I feel having any such sections would defeat the very purpose of this forum.
Trade Well
Diclaimer is mentioned at the bottom of every page in the forum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads