How about a "Grievance" sub-forum ?

[timepass]

Hi TJ,

How about having a "Grievances" sub-forum in "Community Centre" section ? We often have members who want to vent, and we rightly delete those posts. But also often we have other members responding to the offender and then it snowballs. Sometimes even old useful members go off tangent. So have a "Grievance" sub-forum and let them vent there.

I remember that once we had a "Gali Galoch" thread and it didn't see much participation.

PS : Boring markets, upmove is there but feels bearish, what ?

 

[ROCKSTAR55]

Hi TJ,

How about having a "Grievances" sub-forum in "Community Centre" section ? We often have members who want to vent, and we rightly delete those posts. But also often we have other members responding to the offender and then it snowballs. Sometimes even old useful members go off tangent. So have a "Grievance" sub-forum and let them vent there.

I remember that once we had a "Gali Galoch" thread and it didn't see much participation.

PS : Boring markets, upmove is there but feels bearish, what ?

Exactly sir,upmove was there but my mind got blank by reading some bearish post in trading chat.missed good trade.So I request you to also move some biased post there.Thanks.

 

[deba72]

Exactly sir,upmove was there but my mind got blank by reading some bearish post in trading chat.missed good trade.So I request you to also move some biased post there.Thanks.

One of the most popular threads have now been reduced to personal battlefield of two members... one ever-bullish and the other ever-bearish.. It has been going on for quite a long time and surely they spend more time fighting each other than trading... I really wonder how serious traders can find out so much time to post such useless contents so many times in a day...while I really don't care about what they do, these kind of posts without any logic/reasons/charts etc surely affects newbies and inexperienced traders. The post by ROCKSTAR55 is a case in point....

Both have been banned earlier ( multiple times ? ) and then they come back again under new id ..and the story continues...

Any new and novice traders watching that thread, please note, you are getting a very good lesson on how NOT to trade / approach market....and you should thank both of them...

Its high time some corrective actions are taken...either by these guys themselves or admin...

 

[vijkris]

Exactly sir,upmove was there but my mind got blank by reading some bearish post in trading chat.missed good trade.So I request you to also move some biased post there.Thanks.

What if that bearish post really became true and gave u profit, u would have thanked that bearish fellow.
So improve ur method and trust ur method rather than the public's opinion.

This bull bear fight is happening bcos both are giving views on NF.

If there would have been discussion on crude, most of the time, both would have been correct as in crude, nice trend since morning reverses nicely by 8pm . :lol:

 

[ROCKSTAR55]

One of the most popular threads have now been reduced to personal battlefield of two members... one ever-bullish and the other ever-bearish.. It has been going on for quite a long time and surely they spend more time fighting each other than trading... I really wonder how serious traders can find out so much time to post such useless contents so many times in a day...while I really don't care about what they do, these kind of posts without any logic/reasons/charts etc surely affects newbies and inexperienced traders. The post by ROCKSTAR55 is a case in point....

Both have been banned earlier ( multiple times ? ) and then they come back again under new id ..and the story continues...

Any new and novice traders watching that thread, please note, you are getting a very good lesson on how NOT to trade / approach market....and you should thank both of them...

Its high time some corrective actions are taken...either by these guys themselves or admin...

Thanks Sir.Such biased posts can create hesitation in executing trades especially when range b/o trades.As using descreationary system we start looking for BOF instead of BO.Chart reading get converted into illusion.

 

[Smart_trade]

One of the most popular threads have now been reduced to personal battlefield of two members... one ever-bullish and the other ever-bearish.. It has been going on for quite a long time and surely they spend more time fighting each other than trading... I really wonder how serious traders can find out so much time to post such useless contents so many times in a day...while I really don't care about what they do, these kind of posts without any logic/reasons/charts etc surely affects newbies and inexperienced traders. The post by ROCKSTAR55 is a case in point....

Both have been banned earlier ( multiple times ? ) and then they come back again under new id ..and the story continues...

Any new and novice traders watching that thread, please note, you are getting a very good lesson on how NOT to trade / approach market....and you should thank both of them...

Its high time some corrective actions are taken...either by these guys themselves or admin...

Some people consider that posting their bullish or bearish views ,irrespective of what the market is doing, repeatedly is their right and they are doing a great service to other traders by constantly posting their views repeatedly .If the posts are deleted ,they consider it as violation of human rights

Corrective action by those members seems highly unlikely.The only solution is either put a posting ban on these IDs ( and all their further IDs) or delete such posts by all Admin and Moderators.

Smart_trade

 

[timepass]

Oh what the heck... I had an ok day, so no need for a grievance forum.

Guess what ?? My last trade for the day was at 10:35 !!! No trades after that, but an ok day.

 

[ROCKSTAR55]

What if that bearish post really became true and gave u profit, u would have thanked that bearish fellow.
So improve ur method and trust ur method rather than the public's opinion.

This bull bear fight is happening bcos both are giving views on NF.

If there would have been discussion on crude, most of the time, both would have been correct as in crude, nice trend since morning reverses nicely by 8pm . :lol:

I don't trade signals,indicators etc. Only plain charts.So thought process can get corrupted with biased posts and instead of taking trades,we remain SOH.No way to profit from his posts for me because I seriously follow one principle i.e. when in doubt stay out.I was trading stocks which were rangebound.Todays NF was strong upmove so any PA kid can play it easily ,so I hope you didn't face problems.So no visit to TJ from tommorow during trading hours.

 

[HappyLife]

Exactly sir,upmove was there but my mind got blank by reading some bearish post in trading chat.missed good trade.So I request you to also move some biased post there.Thanks.

We all have our own opinion about market so asking to ban someone as because he biased toward bull or bear is not right. Ban someone if he is using abusive language or making some sort of bad comment about somebody.
Noise is everywhere it’s up to you how you filter those noise.

 

[ROCKSTAR55]

We all have our own opinion about market so asking to ban someone as because he biased toward bull or bear is not right. Ban someone if he is using abusive language or making some sort of bad comment about somebody.
Noise is everywhere it’s up to you how you filter those noise.

I think you got banned earlier several times for violating some rules and again you want that all of us must be forced to read that"General Bearish chat" or General speculative chat" thread and you are also one of them who think just deleting their irritating posts is violation of human rights and constitution of india. Nobody in this forum told ban that guuz.we respect freedom of everyone but don't forget to respect rules.