Expert Advice

rajesh_M · #1 19th April 2008, 12:03 PM

Hi guys,
I am newbie in share market field and learning to trade. I had came across advt in papers about paid trading calls from various analyst like Deepak Mohoni,valuenotes. These people give intraday and trading calls. Can any one suggest me good call givers name and whether they really work

sudoku1 · #2 19th April 2008, 12:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rajesh_M

Hi guys,
I am newbie in share market field and learning to trade. I had came across advt in papers about paid trading calls from various analyst like Deepak Mohoni,valuenotes. These people give intraday and trading calls. Can any one suggest me good call givers name and whether they really work

dear rajesh , its easy 2 b lured for making money without working.....though the abv mentioned names r xperts in their fields......they do not risk their own money , the intraday calls work best during boom times ....TARGET ACHIEVED....they say....but in times like the present , the calls generally die down as STOPLOSS ACHIEVED.....
SMS (SYNCHRONISED MATKAA SERVICES) as the call services r called.....
it happens sometimes that the service providers r directly linked to large operaters & these very call providers help the operater 2 easily get in or out of a particular stock @ UR XPENSE.......HOW?
suppose an operater has acquired a large chunk in desired qty in a midcap stock gradually....now its not possible for him 2 get out in in shot....so here is where he gets the help from these callwallas......u get a call 2 buy the same scrip with a wide stoploss whereas on the other hand , the operater is quitely offloading it 2 u........
i would advise u 2 avoid the intraday services since its waste of time & money......
its OK for positional trades in liquid counters......
show me a person in this INDIA who has made bucks from these very intraday callwallas on consistent basis .......
just imagine , if the so called callwallas were so good @ their services , why r they sittng there @ coming every now & then on C artoon N etwork B usiness C hannels.......they would have taken a stake in the BSE & not wasted their time for few thousand rupees .........

pasha · #3 19th April 2008, 08:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sudoku1

these very call providers help the operater 2 easily get in or out of a particular stock @ UR XPENSE.......HOW?
suppose an operater has acquired a large chunk in desired qty in a midcap stock gradually....now its not possible for him 2 get out in in shot....so here is where he gets the help from these callwallas......u get a call 2 buy the same scrip with a wide stoploss whereas on the other hand , the operater is quitely offloading it 2 u........

True.
Even the brokers intraday calls are the same.

rajesh_M · #4 21st April 2008, 04:06 PM

Thank you dear sudoku1 for your advice.
One of my friend has subscribed for delivery calls from Simi Bhaumik. And he is quiet satisfied with service. He says sucesss rate is from 60 to 80% depending on mkt.
Can you suggest me as how should I proceed investing in mkt on short term delivery basis. And what would be my long term strategy to stay in market.
Plz advice as I am seriously wanted to be in this field.

sudoku1 · #5 21st April 2008, 04:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rajesh_M

Thank you dear sudoku1 for your advice.
One of my friend has subscribed for delivery calls from Simi Bhaumik. And he is quiet satisfied with service. He says sucesss rate is from 60 to 80% depending on mkt.
Can you suggest me as how should I proceed investing in mkt on short term delivery basis. And what would be my long term strategy to stay in market.
Plz advice as I am seriously wanted to be in this field.

if u can tell any five good points abt a co in 2 minutes....no need of tips & tipsters.....stay with the nifty 50 biggies....

raosrinivas · #6 21st April 2008, 04:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sudoku1

if u can tell any five good points abt a co in 2 minutes....no need of tips & tipsters.....stay with the nifty 50 biggies....

very true.

rajesh_M · #7 21st April 2008, 05:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sudoku1

if u can tell any five good points abt a co in 2 minutes....no need of tips & tipsters.....stay with the nifty 50 biggies....

Did you mean I must invest only in fundamentally strong companies.

uasish · #8 21st April 2008, 05:19 PM

rajesh_M,

Plz take some time to understand this ...........

http://www.traderji.com/technical-an...html#post38532

Why are you depending on others ,when all these simple methods & the Teacher are available FREE in this Forum.

Asish

rajesh_M · #9 21st April 2008, 07:54 PM

Thank you all senior members who guide all newbies like us. This forum is excellent, and traderji is doing great work.

THETRADER · #10 22nd April 2008, 06:42 PM

If you want to follow any CALLS given by someone, my advice is that you (yourself) follow the calls with mock trading for sometime, and, assess the same. Only then you would know the quality of the calls and whether they are achievable. This would also help you to form your strategy with regard to allocation for each scrip. Atleast bare minimum that you would want is, one who is maintaining his calls till exit. Dont go by we gave you a buy of Nifty Futures at 4423, and, is now xxxx, etc., These promos select only the best call given by them. You need to do your homework even in assessing these calls. There was a guy called stockwhizo (long back during KP days), and, his calls were excellent and unbelievably good, trust me, he was too good to be true, though boasting himself. He is not to be found after one disasterous set of calls. Anyone know of him?
Sharekhan was giving Eagle Eye, where they maintain their calls, and, it appears to be good. You can check out their report (if they have it now).