My Chatroom experience

jaideep · #21 5th September 2006, 08:05 PM

My dear sh50, (or is it Hiren Shah?

),

Sorry pal but I think I confused the Acronym over the months (years?). Your "Each one to learn by himself" is right up my street. Maybe, just maybe that I too am not made for trading the markets whole-time, like you.

Please do give me leads to your writings & posts elsewhere. That will give me great joy Hiren. For example, where do I get to see your article in LIFE POSITIVE? Hope you understand the predicament that I am in. Mail me at jaideep-gc@eth.net if you think fit.

And....my warmest regards to you & best wishes too.

globus · #22 29th November 2006, 11:13 AM

ultimately, do we have a positive feedback on ashwini gujral ?

pchadha74 · #23 7th August 2007, 06:20 PM

Hi Mr SH 50,
I read your post reg your Chatroom experience with Ashwini Gujral and I completely agree with you views and conclusions.
I found a somewhat similar approach to what you wrote about, even I focus abt 70-80% on Nifty trades and the balance on other shares. But what i dont understand in your post is the contradiction thereafter- you said that many people in the chat found Mr Ashwini Gujral as too aggressive.
My question to you is-
1. How is focussing on a single instrument considered too aggressive, in the sence that if you have a higher degree of success in trading an index, that is less risky that trading 10 different stocks (given a particular success rate).
2. Another case may be that together you(or other members) were risking a high proportion on each trade. Would you please let me know what PERCENTAGE of your capital did you risk on each single Nifty trade.

I would appreciate your response, since I am also working on different % risk models (with and without profit targets) to work with in such "skewed" trading style.

Thanks a lot,

Puneet

StockGreen · #24 11th October 2007, 06:40 PM

wonderfully written. It is more of an article than a post..! Good!

bobomonkey · #25 19th December 2007, 05:29 PM

thoroughly enjoyed reading this thread. It was surreal to know that even trade gurus like mr gujral don't depend on trading entirely. And that trading comes with 95% failure rate.

haricnair · #26 1st June 2008, 04:02 PM

I think the Post (Article) about the experience in Ashwani Gujrals chat room is posted by Aswani himself. Don;t you have a suspicious look into such a BIG

post? What you think? I am waiting to subscribe to his chat room as a trial after 10 months (till there I have some other works). After that I will definitely come back to this forum and post the real situation.

Thank you.

Similar Threads for: My Chatroom experience
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
experience using f-chart	prsrivastav	Introductions	2	10th December 2005 11:42 AM
hi everybody this is first visit to this site i donot know how this chatroom works it	mamanek	Introductions	0	1st August 2005 11:12 PM
My experience	rangarajan	Introductions	0	25th July 2005 05:53 PM