Why SAR trading system fails?

Every new trader is trying to trade on signal to signal basis through SAR (Stop And Reverse) system.

But, they are not able to make profit.

Why SAR trading system fails?

What extra indicators are required to add to be profitable in SAR?

Pt,

Sar trading system works fine...with combining moving average ...



I am using this strategy since 2010

See this thread for more details :-

http://www.traderji.com/technical-analysis/87289-nifty-banknifty-using-super-trend.html

hai santhosh,

if possible,

please post the afl here

SAR systems do not require extra indicators, they require proper money management and RRR !
With the same SAR system two different Trades would return results as different as apples and oranges !

all crap . i am seeing people making money on sar systems . you have to be consistent and disciplined

Don't you think that it would have been better if you would have replied in a more polite manner ?

The person is having some confusions as a new trader & you say those confusions as crap.

No where in your answer you have mentioned what kind of consistency & what kind of discipline is required to be successful with SAR .

As Mr. Santosh pointed out..My thread link.thanks

please refer this there more than 2000 post, trading P&L after every month continuously he is upgrading the system..

http://www.icharts.in/forum/lead-alumini-crude-t4986.html

I am using it for almost a year now...