Who is worst ?

rajeshn2007 · #1 3rd June 2008, 05:55 PM

people are fed up with these four analysts on cnbc..

when they are questioned about nifty , they reply :

1. s.sukani - during a down day, he says i told u we are in a beer (yes) market, every oppurtunity is a sell.
on a positive day, he says i told you every dip is a buying opportunity.

2. a.gujral - the answer would be simple. buy with a stop of 300 points target 100 up and vice versa.

3. r.bose - on nifty , i would say buy bata with a stop of 130.

4. e.mathew - same as r.bose, buy some xyz with a stop of 11.5

now, who is worst among the lot?

for me it is difficult to choose, all of them are worst.

Cactus · #2 3rd June 2008, 07:05 PM

if all 4 are wrost then ??

U have forgetten to creat an additional point.

beginner_av · #3 3rd June 2008, 07:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rajeshn2007

people are fed up with these four analysts on cnbc..

when they are questioned about nifty , they reply :

1. s.sukani - during a down day, he says i told u we are in a beer (yes) market, every oppurtunity is a sell.
on a positive day, he says i told you every dip is a buying opportunity.

2. a.gujral - the answer would be simple. buy with a stop of 300 points target 100 up and vice versa.

3. r.bose - on nifty , i would say buy bata with a stop of 130.

4. e.mathew - same as r.bose, buy some xyz with a stop of 11.5

now, who is worst among the lot?

for me it is difficult to choose, all of them are worst.

why do you think they come on TV?

rajeshn2007 · #4 3rd June 2008, 08:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cactus

U have forgetten to creat an additional point.

Yes. you are right.
just typed those names and one is totally confused.

musicjunkie · #5 3rd June 2008, 08:58 PM

They are all geniuses,
the mere fact that I have spent 3 minutes reading and adding this post along with 4 others means they are reaching their goal of being talked about...Sigh* the intricacies of the market.
MJ

AW10 · #6 4th June 2008, 02:45 AM

Everybody is the right to express their views.. it is upto us to decide whether we want to trust everything that we hear as 100% fact or use our brain and discount it.

Have you thought what would happen if they make statements with little margin and they are caught on the wrong foot in the market ? CNBC will not invite them again..

uasish · #7 4th June 2008, 09:07 AM

The more one increases the 'Y' axis (time frame) the more chance of being accurate ,they normally increases time frame to 6 months or 1 Yr.I think with that Leeway most of our Traderji members can be also have same success rate.

apegaonkar · #8 4th June 2008, 10:19 AM

Hi Dear ,
Those who appear on Tv channel are paid for saying some thing ( Changing trader/investor persaption to bail out some hidden big guns).
As We dont know exactly where they are standing , we can watch as joker show.

Its very easy to brag the things but whet it come to investing our own money trouble starts.
Even I am good advisor for others , Frankly spaeking I have been wiped out my 50% profit in market.

They are all bookish. In bull market any tom dick can prove to be best analysis.

Enjoy joker's cirus.

oxusmorouz · #9 4th June 2008, 10:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by uasish

The more one increases the 'Y' axis (time frame) the more chance of being accurate ,they normally increases time frame to 6 months or 1 Yr.I think with that Leeway most of our Traderji members can be also have same success rate.

Not too sure about that but success or no success, there's more chance of their "analysis" being forgotten by people

rajeshn2007 · #10 4th June 2008, 07:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AW10

CNBC will not invite them again..

i think these four on a contract basis with cnbc. i come to know they provide calls thru poweryourtrade also.
whether they are correct or wrong, cnbc will stick to them.
cnbc cannot get a cheaper bargain.

View Poll Results: who is worst?
s.sukani	4	23.53%
a.gujral	4	23.53%
r.bose	4	23.53%
e.mathew	5	29.41%
Voters: 17. You may not vote on this poll