Good Cas who can file properly

What you are saying is correct. But that leaves new guys with just 2 options.

And I would also say many CAs dont know how to file for a trader. One CA he filed ITR1 with derivatives loss carryforwarded in capital gains loss. Such things can be avoided by using the services of above 2 .

No actually it would be helpful for traders in your area. We all know your consistency.

More concerned about mine. hopefully nifty takes some direction

i'm ready to help any trader lemondew bhai !!! don't worry !!!!

Da !!!

Self promotion or promoting somebody is not at all fair !!! i'm against both i never done this nor interested

I am not accusing you for any promotion...my post was in reply to a post which said why only 2 names of CA when so many traders must be filing their returns and getting audit done.

Actually giving a name of CA who has experience in filing traders" returns is not promotion...it is infact helping our trader friends to go to the CA who are experienced in such return filing.

Smart_trade

I do the other way. When I feel someone is doing a good job I spread the word
May be I think it would be good if he gets some work. ..... Off course so long as he is doing a good job. I dont try to promote something I dont like.

I was a sales guy long time back where I had to promote some overpriced useless stuff for my salary. Dont do that now

Correct, and Professionals like CA, Lawyer etc are not allowed to advertise their services like deodorant ads :lol:
Their name is spread by word of mouth and hence its ok on the forum as well.

Normal CA doing audit and IT work finds difficult to understand stock market trading accounts....also filing and helping the traders in case of scrutiny needs special knowledge. Hence CAs with such experience are preffered.

Smart_trade

Da !!! i never said you are accusing me !!! but what i mean to say is mentioning a CA firm won't guarantee that work will be done at most care !!! they are many CA firms who available online ,just take example suri first his ca filied ruturn without p and L and balance sheet, after notice he rectified..there are no specific ca firms for traders ,because still many don't file there return

Just adding my 2 cents as a post here to a PM that I replied to:
Always have an active contact of CA, Lawyer and Doctor in same city, preferably near by.
You never know when you need anyone.