Good Cas who can file properly

canikhil

Well-Known Member
Hello,Nikhil Ji,
I file regular ITR4.I have a query on 44AD where traders declare 8% as a profit.I read this thread completely.

As Govt and IT Dept are strictly monitoring transactions by linking Aadhar to Bank,Aadhar to PAN,Aadhar to Demat etc
Then declaring 8% will be a trouble?

For Example,My TO is 80L.
I am declaring 8% as a profit and paying a tax on it.But my actual profit is much more than it.Isnt it against the law?I am technically paying less tax.If IT dept could see this,wont I get a fine/scrutiny for such a practice?
 

canikhil

Well-Known Member
Hello,Nikhil Ji,
I file regular ITR4.I have a query on 44AD where traders declare 8% as a profit.I read this thread completely.

As Govt and IT Dept are strictly monitoring transactions by linking Aadhar to Bank,Aadhar to PAN,Aadhar to Demat etc
Then declaring 8% will be a trouble?

For Example,My TO is 80L.
I am declaring 8% as a profit and paying a tax on it.But my actual profit is much more than it.Isnt it against the law?I am technically paying less tax.If IT dept could see this,wont I get a fine/scrutiny for such a practice?
as long as your turnover is correct, there is no problem...
 
as long as your turnover is correct, there is no problem...
Actual profit is 8.68L,but 8% wise its 6.40L.
So we are paying 18-20k less tax.

Hope IT Dept wont trouble in future or ask for book of accounts-passbook,ledger,P&L statement etc.

If I consider your statement 100% correct that there is no problem that means Govt itself left a loophole for false practices to be done?

P.S.-I never filed under 44AD,I file a regular ITR4.
 
@canikhil Ji- This question from my friends side.
Once we opt for 44ad scheme we cant change it for next 5yrs.But can we change the nature of business?
I mean,this year we are doing trading f&o,may be next year we'll do some other retail business which comes under 44ad.And 3rd year,we may again resume to trading.So this alteration of business allowed while taking 44ad scheme's benefit?
 
@canikhil Ji- This question from my friends side.
Once we opt for 44ad scheme we cant change it for next 5yrs.But can we change the nature of business?
I mean,this year we are doing trading f&o,may be next year we'll do some other retail business which comes under 44ad.And 3rd year,we may again resume to trading.So this alteration of business allowed while taking 44ad scheme's benefit?
@canikhil Ji,pls reply this query whenever free