Angel broking sold more than what i have

K

kirtibas

Member
#1
#1
dear all members
i really need a help

I have an online account with angel broking pvt. ltd. Prince Anwar shah Road branch Kolkata.
My DP ID is (CDSL ********) / trading client id: KLPA***, using angel pda and angel diet as trading platform.

From few days I am having debit balance. Thats why Mr Rajesh (R.M) of this branch used to sell my holding from his terminal with or without my concern. Once he sold 200 shares of TATASTEEL trading date 12/10/09 without my concern, I informed to their branches but no action had taken till now. And that can be verify by phone conversation recording.

I am not getting any proper response from there Kolkata branches, (guys are very rude in behavior to most of the online clients becoz dont have to face them)
Yesterday on 16th Sep 2009 like every day he was selling my holding from his terminal. The problem arise here ,when I have 100 shares of 3I INFOTECH LTD, But he sold 200 shares from his terminal under my client id. I am making huge loss by short auction. I am attaching the contact note along with this mail. When I called up Mr Rajesh for clarification he completely denied the fact he did it.

i already send mail with attach contact notes to
[email protected],
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]


pls suggest me and guide me

regards
kirtibas
 
K

kirtibas

Member
#2
#2
i want to know which category/ type to select for this kind of grievance
http://www.sebi.gov.in/Complaint.html

Type-I Refund Order/ Allotment Advise.
Type-II Non-receipt of dividend.
Type-III Non-receipt of share certificates after transfer.
Type-IV Debentures.
Type-V Non-receipt of letter of offer for rights issue.
Type-VI Collective Investment Schemes
Type-VII Mutual Funds/ Venture Capital Funds/ Foreign Venture Capital Investors/ Foreign Institutional Investors/ Portfolio Managers, Custodians

Type-VIII Brokers/ Securities Lending Intermediaries/ Merchant Bankers/ Registrars and Transfer Agents/ Debenture Trustees/ Bankers to Issue/ Underwriters/ Credit Rating Agencies/ Depository Participants

Type-IX Securities Exchanges/ Clearing and Settlement Organizations/ Depositories
Type-X Derivative Trading
Type-XI Corporate Governance/ Corporate Restructuring/ Substantial Acquisition and Takeovers/ Buyback / Delisting / Compliance With Listing Conditions
 
SavantGarde

SavantGarde

Well-Known Member
#3
#3
Type-VIII Brokers/ Securities Lending Intermediaries/ Merchant Bankers/ Registrars and Transfer Agents/ Debenture Trustees/ Bankers to Issue/ Underwriters/ Credit Rating Agencies/ Depository Participants

SavantGarde


kirtibas said:
i want to know which category/ type to select for this kind of grievance
http://www.sebi.gov.in/Complaint.html

Type-I Refund Order/ Allotment Advise.
Type-II Non-receipt of dividend.
Type-III Non-receipt of share certificates after transfer.
Type-IV Debentures.
Type-V Non-receipt of letter of offer for rights issue.
Type-VI Collective Investment Schemes
Type-VII Mutual Funds/ Venture Capital Funds/ Foreign Venture Capital Investors/ Foreign Institutional Investors/ Portfolio Managers, Custodians

Type-VIII Brokers/ Securities Lending Intermediaries/ Merchant Bankers/ Registrars and Transfer Agents/ Debenture Trustees/ Bankers to Issue/ Underwriters/ Credit Rating Agencies/ Depository Participants

Type-IX Securities Exchanges/ Clearing and Settlement Organizations/ Depositories
Type-X Derivative Trading
Type-XI Corporate Governance/ Corporate Restructuring/ Substantial Acquisition and Takeovers/ Buyback / Delisting / Compliance With Listing Conditions
Click to expand...
 
K

kirtibas

Member
#4
#4
thank u very much sir,
sir i want to know what are the documents / proofs i have to produce to establish my complain, against such activity.
can ip address used for verification?

thanks
kirtibas
 
MurAtt

MurAtt

Well-Known Member
#5
#5
Well, I just could not stop myself and called my broker.

This is what he told me : Its a win-win situation. Tell the RM to prove that you told him to sell the scrips. They should have a phone recording of the order you have placed over phone else its illegal and the RM and/or his company is liable. Also, the 100 shares of a particular scrip being sold etc is never done in case of debit balance. It is always position sizing i.e. if you have 100 TISCO, 200 UCO Bank, 25 Telco, 10 Infy etc THEN part holdings of EACH scrip will be sold by the SYTEM through AUTOMATIC TRADE/ORDER on the server and NOT PHYSICALLY BY RM.

ALSO you can go to the branch and speak to the Branch Manager AND RECORD THE CONVERSATION TOO.(which may or may not help as such)

Also more details are required. Have you signed a copy of the C/N given to you by the broker as acceptance? Have u gotten the C/N within 24hrs of the EOD of trade?
 
MurAtt

MurAtt

Well-Known Member
#6
#6
Just one more thing .... (Better to be safe than to be sorry i.e.)

Be a little prudent and do not jump into it as I have said it. Get another opinion (from a friend or a fr of a friend etc) and then do the needful coz if something goes wrong i.e. I am mis-informed then you will be more on backfoot than u already are ...

Just a precaution ...

:)
 
K

kirtibas

Member
#7
#7
thanks u very much.
i got c/n @ y'day nite (not signed) its attachment via e-mail
phone conversation is one good prove,

how to show that RM of this branch modify my bids physically from his terminal?
how he sold 200 shares since i had only 100 shares in my holding?

funny thing about this prince anwasha rd. branch- branch manages is very new may be 15days -1month.
that RM acting like branch manager (bcoz he thinks new branch manager dont know anything about capital mkt since he's from insurance background)

i already talk to md masud alam (branch manager) he try to convince me.
but RM (Rajesh Chakroborty) hes behavior is very very rude last nite when i called up he used 1 slang also.

so i want to raise my voice against him to topmost lavel

thanks and regards
kirtibas
 
Placebo

Placebo

Well-Known Member
#9
#9
I have an account with angel broking in pune.I'll speak to the RM and find out if you can do anything about the situation in which you are in. And if your RM is acting smart and using abusive language then give it back to him in his face. Don't take sh** from such manipulative people.

Cheers
 
SavantGarde

SavantGarde

Well-Known Member
#10
#10
Hi Kirtibas,

a) Burden Of Proving That You Gave The Sell Order Is Brokers.
b) Even Incase Of Debit Balance, One Has To Be Informed 2 Days Before Incase Of Selling RMS Because Of Debit.

So All The Proving Has To Be Done By The Broker Not You.

Looks Like Brokers System Of RMS Is Not As Per SEBI Guidelines Or Else Short Sell Wouldn't Have Happened.

If They Are Abusive In Their Communication, I Suggest You Recod It...Next Time.

Happy & Safer Investing

SavantGarde

kirtibas said:
thank u very much sir,
sir i want to know what are the documents / proofs i have to produce to establish my complain, against such activity.
can ip address used for verification?

thanks
kirtibas
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
nac [HELP] From where we can download reports - Angel Broking Brokers & Trading Platforms 0
R Reliance PP and Angel Broking General Trading & Investing Chat 0
Chittorgarh Angel Broking IPO Opens on Sep 22, 2020 Initial Public Offers (IPO's) 1
S Is Angel Broking good for trading involving large amounts? Brokers & Trading Platforms 1
S Margin Calculation on Angel Broking Brokers & Trading Platforms 0

Similar threads