TECHNICAL ANALYSIS how far right?

#1
Hi everybody, recently i thought frequently, how far does technical analysis, charts are right?Does analysists try to control market,or nifty or indivdual stock in the name of technical analysis?computing past highs and lows within a chart in various terms and themselves setting targets and lows,try to keep in control/level.Does this is an intelluctuals ,prodigy skill /manipulation?If suppose , technical analysis has not been discoverd it will go ahead than TA targets or will fall below than TA indicates according to their individulal performances or economical situations.How far is this correct? Please share your opinoins . Thank u.

(But im also trying to learn TA , and imply what i learned , just tunneling my skull, thats why asked.)
 

jahan

Well-Known Member
#2
Hi everybody, recently i thought frequently, how far does technical analysis, charts are right?Does analysists try to control market,or nifty or indivdual stock in the name of technical analysis?computing past highs and lows within a chart in various terms and themselves setting targets and lows,try to keep in control/level.Does this is an intelluctuals ,prodigy skill /manipulation?If suppose , technical analysis has not been discoverd it will go ahead than TA targets or will fall below than TA indicates according to their individulal performances or economical situations.How far is this correct? Please share your opinoins . Thank u.

(But im also trying to learn TA , and imply what i learned , just tunneling my skull, thats why asked.)
Hello,

TECHNICAL ANALYSIS how far right?
...."its depends upon person to person" and depends upon how far(extent) ur going to use it, i.e from market selection process to trade exit.

.....,but what i learn in my trading career is that, TA is only 5-10% responsible for trading success, another 90-95% is ur own Psychology and Riskmanagement.

see...... charts/markets are always right, but interpretation of charts/markets are again depends upon individuals....thats why there are differences in person to person Analysis of charts/markets and whoever tries/thinks ..he can control the markets..its his/her sure way to go to failure.

TA is only representation of market/market participants at given time.its nothing to do with prediction of future market-condition.

yes...i agree that there is manipulation, but whatever it may be chart gonna print the data and a good/intellectual market participant will catch that move.

see.....in my opinion 80 out 100 traders actually don't no how markets(Market Auction Process) will work,which causes them to rise questions like u asked.

my suggestion to u is... first know how Market Auction Process/cycles occur.
then jump to TA..while ur learning TA don't predict the market act on the present situation of the market, and give respect to markets, in the sense follow ur rules and money management.:thumb:
 
#3
1.TA is only representation of market/market participants at given time.its nothing to do with prediction of future market-condition.

2.yes...i agree that there is manipulation, but whatever it may be chart gonna print the data and a good/intellectual market participant will catch that move.

3.see.....in my opinion 80 out 100 traders actually don't no how markets(Market Auction Process) will work,which causes them to rise questions like u asked.

my suggestion to u is... first know how Market Auction Process/cycles occur.
then jump to TA..while ur learning TA don't predict the market act on the present situation of the market, and give respect to markets, in the sense follow ur rules and money management.:thumb:
Hi Jahan , thanks for ur opinions.

1.me too think the same and expressed in other words.
2.even im not having lot of experiences often i realize that changes, thats why i raised the question.
3.dear, i knew the basics of trades bids - offers- negotiations . im not asking in that way, does the analysts predictions affect the actual systems? i think defenitely have some part i experienced in my own.

thanks sir.
 

jahan

Well-Known Member
#4
Hi Jahan , thanks for ur opinions.

1.me too think the same and expressed in other words.
2.even im not having lot of experiences often i realize that changes, thats why i raised the question.
3.dear, i knew the basics of trades bids - offers- negotiations . im not asking in that way, does the analysts predictions affect the actual systems? i think defenitely have some part i experienced in my own.

thanks sir.
Hello,

Market Auction Process/cycles means not only (Retail Auction) Bid-Ask, and negotiation,its actually means the theory/phases involved in the process......

for example....every market has, in particular phase at a given point of time....

the topic is little bit lengthy.... i will try to demonstrate in simple terms.
.......
Market Auction Process...
It has three Phases.....1)vertical phase
2)End of vertical Phase.
3)Horizontal Phase.
.... and each phase will tell different activity of market participants..

it will guide us whether Accumulation...... of buyers/sellers going on or whether the Distribution of buyers/sellers(profit realizing point)....

did u know why our orders not filled when we are right.....its due to vertical phase of the market.

did u know why our orders get filled at wrong time even though anticipated direction is right and we get stopped out...due to horizontal phase.

did u know why our orders get filled when we are wrong...due to End of vertical phase and market will move in opposite direction of our order.

.......blah....blah....

u asked whether analyst predictions effect the actual system?
i say no markets gonna go wherever they destined to go..no body will stop them or predict them accurately..

see ...Prediction and Anticipation both are different ..we can only Anticipate not to predict.....

u ask any analyst to show his/her trading Accounts/performance result based on their calls/predictions...they never show ...bcoz they are Academics not traders.
Regards,
 
Last edited:
#5
It has three Phases.....1)vertical phase
2)End of vertical Phase.
3)Horizontal Phase.

it will guide us whether Accumulation...... of buyers/sellers going on or whether the Distribution of buyers/sellers(profit realizing point)....

did u know why our orders not filled when we are right.....its due to vertical phase of the market.

I CORRELATE THIS WITH UPTREND

did u know why our orders get filled at wrong time even though anticipated direction is right and we get stopped out...due to horizontal phase.

TRENDLINE BREAKOUT

did u know why our orders get filled when we are wrong...due to End of vertical phase and market will move in opposite direction of our order.

DOWNTREND .

Thanks for ur comments sir,

One more question , how to find the actual delivery volumes and intraday volumes seperately in the volumes shown, if a share rises some percent and at the same day goes below how can i find the volumes which is major (i.e rise volume or low)

thanks sir.
 

Similar threads