Technical Vs Fundamental

A

aircraft

Member
#1
#1
For me it looks like this. Fundamentals solely depend on company fundamentals and earnings data where as Technicals completely derive their basis from actual market data. Which among these two is a better candidate for a person to whose only intention is to make money?

Here goes the answer:

I think technicals are far better than fundamentals because it is ultimately the market determining the price for a security and not the company earnings directly. Though company earning guide the overall health of the security price it is the peoples sentiment which moves the price up and down. So the technicals give a clear market sentiment picture of the actual share holders as well as some fundamental insight.

Finally all it is required is to make money from price difference between the buy and sell. It is easy to ride sentiments rather than fundamentals which change in due long course of time. Hence technicals is a clear winner for me.
 
C

Cactus

Active Member
#2
#2
Re: Techincal Vs Fundamental

Wow......the battle can be won by technicals & fundamentals.......:)

............Good news..........:)

then why 90% losers......around the world...........:rolleyes:


aircraft said:
For me it looks like this. Fundamentals solely depend on company fundamentals and earnings data where as Technicals completely derive their basis from actual market data. Which among these two is a better candidate for a person to whose only intention is to make money?

Here goes the answer:

I think technicals are far better than fundamentals because it is ultimately the market determining the price for a security and not the company earnings directly. Though company earning guide the overall health of the security price it is the peoples sentiment which moves the price up and down. So the technicals give a clear market sentiment picture of the actual share holders as well as some fundamental insight.

Finally all it is required is to make money from price difference between the buy and sell. It is easy to ride sentiments rather than fundamentals which change in due long course of time. Hence technicals is a clear winner for me.
Click to expand...
 
Saint

Saint

Banned
#3
#3
Re: Techincal Vs Fundamental

Cactus said:
Wow......the battle can be won by technicals & fundamentals.......:)

............Good news..........:)

then why 90% losers......around the world...........:rolleyes:
Click to expand...
Coz' they follow no strategy of any sort,no analysis of any type......they buy coz the next door neighbour's brother-in-law's cousin brother said so.....they gamble,and they lose!

Saint
 
C

Cactus

Active Member
#4
#4
Re: Techincal Vs Fundamental

Offcourse Saint.

But, if we forget tip system and consider the facts those are responsible for profit/loss in long/short term scenario………my opinion goes like this…..

Human behaviour/Trading Dicipline. 60%
Technicals 30%
Fundamentals 10%

Regards.

Saint said:
Coz' they follow no strategy of any sort,no analysis of any type......they buy coz the next door neighbour's brother-in-law's cousin brother said so.....they gamble,and they lose!

Saint
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
A

aircraft

Member
#5
#5
It is not the winning or losing. Markets never say or do nothing by which you will be made to lose. It is you who play. Markets at the very first step treat everybody equally. It is we who turn the opportunity for loss or a profit. Why blame market for this. Losing is purely our inefficiency. So better let us correct ourselves instead of working on markets winning or losing statistics.

People with a trading discipline flaw will never succeed in trading.

A BAD WORKMAN ALWAYS BLAMES OF TOOLS.
 
C

Cactus

Active Member
#6
#6
aircraft said:
Why blame market for this. Losing is purely our inefficiency. So better let us correct ourselves instead of working on markets winning or losing statistics.

People with a trading discipline flaw will never succeed in trading.

A BAD WORKMAN ALWAYS BLAMES OF TOOLS.
Click to expand...
Where I Blamed market ?:confused:
 
A

aircraft

Member
#7
#7
The whole post carries a pessimistic approach trying to provide statistics on winning and losing people. Why comment on losing side, Why not the 10% who won cannot be considered?. It is we who take the side and not the market trying to make us to take other sides boss. It the whole attitude which counts in trading. 90% lose because of discipline flaw and fear of losing over again. They finally leave the arena. p:p
 
A

amritak1952

Member
#8
#8
dear seniors ,
with due respect i have yet to come across to the person whether fundamantalist or technicals who have not lost some money in the market
amrit
 
R

rds1933

New Member
#9
#9
In the long run, fundamentals may have relevance. However, in the short and intermediate considerations, technical analysis may give far higher returns. Technicals discount valuations too, in my opinion. I'm not an expert, so am ready to be corrected.
 
C

Cactus

Active Member
#10
#10
aircraft said:
Why comment on losing side, Why not the 10% who won cannot be considered?.
Click to expand...
No comments on losing or winning side, the comment was made on thinking that one can win the battel with fundamentals/technicals.........without understanding risk/money management/dicipline/ correct assumption........

aircraft said:
It is we who take the side and not the market trying to make us to take other sides boss. It the whole attitude which counts in trading. 90% lose because of discipline flaw and fear of losing over again.
Click to expand...
Where did u mentioned DISCIPLINE in ur first post ?

There are several factors those make sombody loser or winer.......regardless to mention.......how long it take to learn.......
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
R Backtesting with fundamental and technical data, different entry & exit criteria Algo & Automated Trading 6
OptimSignals How do you advice to learn technical analysis rather than fundamental in trading ? Welcome 0
A AI based software for fundamental and technical analysis Advanced Trading Strategies 3
apegaonkar9 Why many technical and fundamental expert analysts fails in long run ? Members Discussion Forums 1
headstrong007 ALL FREE Web links: charts.news feed.trading tools.technical/fundamental information Websites 40

Similar threads