Restoring Traders/Investors Faith into Investing

Einstein, what are your thoughts on Astra Microwave Products?

I noticed most companies are only able to stabilize on markets after having annual sales of 250 crore. The accounting numbers on this stock seem very good for the last 10 years.
 

Einstein

Well-Known Member
Something where I really need to go through whole annual reports to understand the company's cash flow and future profitability. Will let you know here soon.
 

Einstein

Well-Known Member
@mvkarthik


finally someone is asking good questions here. In past, I have tried many valuation models before, extensively and heavily on Indian firms, and all have their own cons and pros.. but the things is that once you get an intrinsic value (average of best speculative price as per the underlying business), you're pretty much a winner. But the problem with Berkshire hathway is that you cannot do this on every underlying subsidy of a firm(due to huge diversification and future uncertainties), this is more like evaluating an index where underlying assets changes quickly. so instead of going through whole business buffett has just wrote about an open source type valuation cum speculation model. consider this just as an projection model, which will not work on all businesses. It is not an effective way of evaluating small businesses, cash flow based valuations are still the best way of evaluating a business for general investors.
 

mvkarthik

Well-Known Member
Einstein my humble request to you to start a new thread on teaching value investing, that will be so helpful to beginners investors like me

thank you

Karthik.
 

mvkarthik

Well-Known Member
US total market cap to US GDP is 126.5%
India total market cap to India GDP is 77%
Indian stock market is Fair Valued
Us stock market is Significantly Overvalued

Total Market Cap / GDP Valuation
< 50% ----------------Significantly Undervalued
50% 75%----------Modestly Undervalued
75% 90% ---------Fair Valued
90% 115% -------- Modestly Overvalued
> 115%----------------Significantly Overvalued
 
Last edited:

Mr.G

Well-Known Member
US total market cap to US GDP is 126.5%
India total market cap to India GDP is 77%
Indian stock market is Fair Valued
Us stock market is Significantly Overvalued

Total Market Cap / GDP Valuation
< 50% ----------------Significantly Undervalued
50% 75%----------Modestly Undervalued
75% 90% ---------Fair Valued
90% 115% -------- Modestly Overvalued
> 115%----------------Significantly Overvalued
How did you prove the above assumptions? Any studies or research you have read or done?
 

Prataap_2013

Well-Known Member
India's market cap to GDP has more upside

India’s market capitalization-to-gross domestic product (GDP) ratio has climbed to 75.34%. That’s a gain of 14.6 percentage points since the beginning of this year, the highest among all major markets barring Hong Kong.

The US, the other bright spot in the world economy, according to the International Monetary Fund, has seen its market cap-to-GDP ratio grow only 1.5 percentage points this year. But then, its current market cap is almost 35% higher than its GDP.

However, it should also be noted that the current market cap-to-GDP ratio is still lower than the 10-year average of 78%. Secondly, India’s share of world market cap at 2.42% is still lower than its share of global economic output (2.64%). So that indicates there is some way to go for the markets yet.