What causes the difference in performance between Berger Paints and Orbit Exports?

#1
Berger Paints, Supreme Industries and eClerx outperformed since 2015.

Orbit Exports, Hexaware and HCL Tech underperformed from mid 2015 to mid 2016 despite strong accounting numbers and low valuation.

When I looked at the accounting numbers of Berger Paints and Orbit Exports, Orbit Exports comes out as the clear winner (except for CROIC and Alt Man Z score) but the stock performance suffered from June 2015 to May 2016.

Did I over look something? The CROIC and Alt Man Z scores of Bajaj Corp are very high but Bajaj Corp underperformed from mid 2015 to mid 2016.
 

Similar threads