Am I ready to go live or should I test my system a little longer for a while.

#1
http://www.myfxbook.com/members/wasim/alpari-demo/1079172

^^^ I am testing one strategy in demo for the last almost 2 months and it is showing pretty good results. Overall strategy is very simple in which I throw random buys and sells on a particular pair (mainly EUR/USD and GBP/USD) keeping in mind the bigger trend or small trend picture in mind. If the trend is long I will still add shorts but relatively less then longs. There is no SL and there is only TP. TP's are added to the nearest swings in most of the cases. Only risk management I do is to keep the lots sizes small as compared to the overall equity. The inbuilt disadvantage in this strategy is the floating loss which is unavaoidable and the only solutionI try to apply is to get more TP's so that the overall profit is always more then the losses. This is not a Grid or AntiGrid system neither this is a martingale or hedging system or pyramiding system(even though sometimes pyramiding and hedging happens automatically due to random buys and sell). There is no EA and I only add positions after my day job for only 3 to four hours manually.


Apart from this short term trading strategy I am strong supporter of trend following strategy and I am trading real money for last couple of years in Equities with good results.

Awaiting your responses and criticism :)
 

Galts Gulch

Well-Known Member
#2
http://www.myfxbook.com/members/wasim/alpari-demo/1079172

^^^ I am testing one strategy in demo for the last almost 2 months and it is showing pretty good results. Overall strategy is very simple in which I throw random buys and sells on a particular pair (mainly EUR/USD and GBP/USD) keeping in mind the bigger trend or small trend picture in mind. If the trend is long I will still add shorts but relatively less then longs. There is no SL and there is only TP. TP's are added to the nearest swings in most of the cases. Only risk management I do is to keep the lots sizes small as compared to the overall equity. The inbuilt disadvantage in this strategy is the floating loss which is unavaoidable and the only solutionI try to apply is to get more TP's so that the overall profit is always more then the losses. This is not a Grid or AntiGrid system neither this is a martingale or hedging system or pyramiding system(even though sometimes pyramiding and hedging happens automatically due to random buys and sell). There is no EA and I only add positions after my day job for only 3 to four hours manually.


Apart from this short term trading strategy I am strong supporter of trend following strategy and I am trading real money for last couple of years in Equities with good results.

Awaiting your responses and criticism :)
Ask yourself "AM I READY TO GO LIVE?
Others can never and should not answer this for you ....
In any trading ... 20% is about the market ... 30% is about the strategy ... AND 50% is about The TRADER ..
Short term / positional trading ... are all just terminologies .... Trading is about The Psyche of The Trader ..
My cents .......:thumb::thumb::thumb:
 

Galts Gulch

Well-Known Member
#3
http://www.myfxbook.com/members/wasim/alpari-demo/1079172

^^^ I am testing one strategy in demo for the last almost 2 months and it is showing pretty good results. Overall strategy is very simple in which I throw random buys and sells on a particular pair (mainly EUR/USD and GBP/USD) keeping in mind the bigger trend or small trend picture in mind. If the trend is long I will still add shorts but relatively less then longs. There is no SL and there is only TP. TP's are added to the nearest swings in most of the cases. Only risk management I do is to keep the lots sizes small as compared to the overall equity. The inbuilt disadvantage in this strategy is the floating loss which is unavaoidable and the only solutionI try to apply is to get more TP's so that the overall profit is always more then the losses. This is not a Grid or AntiGrid system neither this is a martingale or hedging system or pyramiding system(even though sometimes pyramiding and hedging happens automatically due to random buys and sell). There is no EA and I only add positions after my day job for only 3 to four hours manually.


Apart from this short term trading strategy I am strong supporter of trend following strategy and I am trading real money for last couple of years in Equities with good results.

Awaiting your responses and criticism :)
And I'm not impressed with few numbers in your statement ...
359 trades in less than 30 trading days ... BIG NO ...
Worst trade is higher than the best trade .... This does not talk good about Money Management ... :mad::mad::mad:
Consistent higher draw down ... again lack of planning and money management ..
Even if you want to demo trade, trade a much smaller account size ... say 3,000 or maximum 5000$ demo accounts ... This will not only tell you more about the strategy, it will tighten your money management ...
Trade less ... earn more ... less stress ...
Trade higher TF ...
Feel free to ask me any doubts / questions ...
I was also a newbie ... 8 years back ..
All the best ... :thumb::thumb::thumb:
 
#4
Of course you're ready to go live ... trading demo is just a waste of time besides it doesn't matter how well you do in demo because you'll lose your first account or first few accounts anyway ... that's just the way it is .... so might as well take the plunge
 
#5
Of course you're ready to go live ... trading demo is just a waste of time besides it doesn't matter how well you do in demo because you'll lose your first account or first few accounts anyway ... that's just the way it is .... so might as well take the plunge
I think it is not a wast of time (With all my respect to what you posted), but it should not be valued as: I know it now and now I can beat the market. Here your above post tells the absolute true.

I think it is fine to use any demo to test what we already know about trading and to test if the plattform can serve what we are asking for or have in mind we want to use. But here we again come to the point where we have to know what we want to see or use in our trading.

Take care and have a nice weekend / Dan :)
 
#6
And I'm not impressed with few numbers in your statement ...
359 trades in less than 30 trading days ... BIG NO ...
Worst trade is higher than the best trade .... This does not talk good about Money Management ... :mad::mad::mad:
Consistent higher draw down ... again lack of planning and money management ..
Even if you want to demo trade, trade a much smaller account size ... say 3,000 or maximum 5000$ demo accounts ... This will not only tell you more about the strategy, it will tighten your money management ...
Trade less ... earn more ... less stress ...
Trade higher TF ...
Feel free to ask me any doubts / questions ...
I was also a newbie ... 8 years back ..
All the best ... :thumb::thumb::thumb:
Thank you for your valuable input. I am not impressed either hence I asked the question in the first place. :)
I am already testing it on a small demo a/c with very tiny lot sizes to reduce the drawdown Here is the link https://www.myfxbook.com/portfolio/swissquote/1097176
 
#7
I think it is not a wast of time (With all my respect to what you posted), but it should not be valued as: I know it now and now I can beat the market. Here your above post tells the absolute true.

I think it is fine to use any demo to test what we already know about trading and to test if the plattform can serve what we are asking for or have in mind we want to use. But here we again come to the point where we have to know what we want to see or use in our trading.

Take care and have a nice weekend / Dan :)
Thank you somatung... Yes I am doing forward testing to only determine whether the strategy will work or not. Lets hope the journey is smooth on live a/c as well
 

stoch

Active Member
#8
http://www.myfxbook.com/members/wasim/alpari-demo/1079172

^^^ I am testing one strategy in demo for the last almost 2 months and it is showing pretty good results. Overall strategy is very simple in which I throw random buys and sells on a particular pair (mainly EUR/USD and GBP/USD) keeping in mind the bigger trend or small trend picture in mind. If the trend is long I will still add shorts but relatively less then longs. There is no SL and there is only TP. TP's are added to the nearest swings in most of the cases. Only risk management I do is to keep the lots sizes small as compared to the overall equity. The inbuilt disadvantage in this strategy is the floating loss which is unavaoidable and the only solutionI try to apply is to get more TP's so that the overall profit is always more then the losses. This is not a Grid or AntiGrid system neither this is a martingale or hedging system or pyramiding system(even though sometimes pyramiding and hedging happens automatically due to random buys and sell). There is no EA and I only add positions after my day job for only 3 to four hours manually.


Apart from this short term trading strategy I am strong supporter of trend following strategy and I am trading real money for last couple of years in Equities with good results.

Awaiting your responses and criticism :)

Very good results for two months :thumb:. I have a good feeling about your strategy, as it's pretty simple, based on evident market properties and don't require much calculations on top of this. Frankly, I wouldn't have moved to Hotforex, if Alpari didn't rip me off because of so called off-market trades. Anyway, be careful with them.
 
#9
Very good results for two months :thumb:. I have a good feeling about your strategy, as it's pretty simple, based on evident market properties and don't require much calculations on top of this. Frankly, I wouldn't have moved to Hotforex, if Alpari didn't rip me off because of so called off-market trades. Anyway, be careful with them.

Thank you very much for your opinion. I also have a good feeling about this but there is one more test I want to do before I make the big leap of faith. As you see this strategy work very well in the consolidation market as EurUsd is consolidating for the last two month. My research tells me that market trends for like 20% of the time and the rest 80% is the combination of small trends and consolidation. So I want to also test in this strong trending market also. Lets hope for the best :)
 
#10
Of course you're ready to go live ... trading demo is just a waste of time besides it doesn't matter how well you do in demo because you'll lose your first account or first few accounts anyway ... that's just the way it is .... so might as well take the plunge
Totally disagreed with you, Demo Trading is heart of Forex Trading. without practising on demo you cant go to live trading.