Can tipsters be rated, like seller are on ebay?

Everybody is aware of the seller rating system on ebay. A seller who falters on his commitment get a negative rating and all buyers / prospective buyers get to see what other buyers have to say about that particular seller.

Can this be implemented on traderji? Here, all the seniors like Traderji himself, CV, Saint, Uasish, Ratan Jain, Kalyan, bv-praveen, aca_trader, amitt29 and the likes can voice their views for that particular tipster and/or his calls/tips. And all the beginners like myself can read those views first before acting on that tip or call. There can be a system that after a certain number/percentage of negative points, the tipster gets banned automatically OR even if he is not banned, ppl will obviously not look at his calls which carry such a high percentage of negative points.

This can avoid verbal duels which entail after a senior finds an irresponsible tipster who is maybe baiting for new clients.

Ofcourse, ebay earns a hefty commissions on sales, which traderji doesn't, so i don't know whether this is possible.

Regards
Nitesh

Theres something called self respect,i am afraid the anonymity provided by the web is used as acting in the interests of the institutions.Or by making ppl indulge in operator driven stocks.So when nifty cracks 600 points these ppl are not seen.

Anyone can give tips,infact when this become a self feeding mechanism all the tip seekers and the subscribers,students buy and become part of the operator cartel.Believe me 100 ppl buying 1 lot of rpl each can trigger a huge move.

Talk abt timing.

Where are u guys when I need you to fight against people who are abusing traderji?

Amit you should come to Hitesh's thread and give him a piece of your mind too

And arzoo.singh. He pisses everyone off on the forum, bigtime...

NO.NOT ME.I ENJOY HIS POSTS GREATLY.

BUT WHAT IS THE NEED OF THAT? WHO IS TRADING THESE CALLS? IF ANYBODY IS TRADING WITH A MINDSET OF LIGHT TIMEPASS,THEN HE/SHE CAN TAKE ANYBODY'S CALL,NOT ONLY THE SAID TIPSTERS,BUT OF THE PANWALA,THE DHOBI,DUDHWALA.....LIFE IS A CHARM THEN.
IF ANYBODY THINKS THAT PEOPLE WITH MINIMUM 15-20 LAKH CAPITAL WILL TRADE THE CALLS OF SUCH PERSONS WHOM THEY DON'T KNOW,NEVER SEEN,THEN HE SHHOULD CHANGE HIS MIND - PEOPLE ARE NOT THAT FOOL,THEY KNOW TO PROTECT THEIR MONEY.
ANYWAYS UR IDEA IS NOT BAD zeekid.BUT Traderji ALREADY HAS A USER REPUTATION SYSTEM IN PLACE.RATE ANY POST AS POSITIVE OR NEGATIVE,BY THAT WAY PEOPLE CAN SEE A TIPSTER'S REPUTATION AND WILL BE CAREFUL TO TAKE 'CALLS' IF ANYTHING NEGATIVE IS THERE.
AND WE CAN MAKE FUN IN THE MEAN TIME.

hi
well..i do agree ,,something should be done and strict action should taken ,, weighting the % of the calls given right/wrong irrespective of mkt... and then the particular person should be notified of ..its % ,,but
ITS IMPOSSIBLE TO DO...this i think ... because who is going to track everyones call ,,and to whta limit /time,,not possible

renu

its too ambiguous.... i only get to see either a red dot OR a green dot OR a grey dot (the grey one's must be the good ones - as "grey" refere to the grey matter --> brain!!!

compare the present user rep systems with what is suggested -> wherein you can "see" what rating has been given to the thread/poster by the likes of Saint/CV etc.

why not..... infact, i got the idea after reading the 'hitesh' thread wherein you yourself and Ratan Jain took time and effort to prove a point wrong (Ratanji was more vociferous )!!

The same job can be done in the new system, without the fiery verbal exchanges and multiple posts, it needs only one reputation comment and rating.

Regards
Nitesh

I seriously doubt,because these ppl dont have any self respect.They are by products of the modern culture.Dont have any old code values.