Trading adivisory...help!

Asia Etrader · #11 16th August 2007, 07:21 PM

Are they every trade you have ever made? I believe you have had successful trades but I dont believe they all have been.

Dev Mookerji · #12 16th August 2007, 07:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Asia Etrader

Are they every trade you have ever made? I believe you have had successful trades but I dont believe they all have been.

No dear, I am a very small trader. I can't take position in all of my recommendations........Otherwise, I should have become Millionaire if not Billiionaire

...Also I have lost heavily in the past, and restarted my trading from 2007 only

Thats the reason for starting my advisory services, otherwise who cares those things

dev mookerji

stock_trading · #13 16th August 2007, 07:53 PM

Dev do you want me to help ASIA ETRADER gather post about your losses

Ha ha . I thought in that post u had mentioned you will never post again in this forum

Anyways all the best ;

Dev Mookerji · #14 16th August 2007, 08:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stock_trading

Dev do you want me to help ASIA ETRADER gather post about your losses

Ha ha . I thought in that post u had mentioned you will never post again in this forum

Anyways all the best ;

Prove me wrong dear. I have predicted in an early stage about the correction, which u guys are watching now. Now it is upto u, whether to accept it or not

I know u are talking about this post....I am helping u to find out...

http://www.traderji.com/104485-post42.html

gud luck
dev mookerji

pr_shetty · #15 16th August 2007, 11:49 PM

Dear Dev,

I have seen many of your posts on this site and found them to be very informative and to the point. I am new to stock markets would appreciate if you help me pick some gems for a capital of Rs.50000.

thanks in advance

Dev Mookerji · #16 18th August 2007, 09:00 AM

Rao Garu,

http://www.traderji.com/108211-post7.html

Waiting for your reply

dev mookerji

rajesh.sadhanala · #17 18th August 2007, 10:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dev Mookerji

Rao Garu,

http://www.traderji.com/108211-post7.html

Waiting for your reply

dev mookerji

Those just you were highlighting is not returns my dear friend.

You say cup and handle formed in so and so date and ur exit never planned. So how can u claim 42%. That is not a trade setup. Its just like recommendation which will never work in real time environment.

ur profit calculation is simply high and low of some period which is very wrong. Till you dont mention ur exit criteria, ur paper position is also still intact and will affect.

I m not criticizing that u r not good but u r just trying to proove u r right. See Cipla you said that it will reach 200 again but it didn't so ur prediction failed. Now u can claim that market is corrected and it could be the reason. You also said that u predict market is correcting then how can u give buy calls on Cipla, Arvind Mills and so on.

Sorry to say but you need to rethink before you ask others to venture out 50k based on ur handling. Dont try to proove that u r 100% correct because no one is. It is always probability game.

Raj

Dev Mookerji · #18 18th August 2007, 10:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rajesh.sadhanala

Sorry to say but you need to rethink before you ask others to venture out 50k based on ur handling. Dont try to proove that u r 100% correct because no one is. It is always probability game.

Raj

I never told I am 100% correct, nobody can be like that.

But why did I started the thread go to the first posting, u will came to know the reasons.

Let us see what can be done.

dev

raosrinivas · #19 18th August 2007, 10:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dev Mookerji

Rao Garu,

http://www.traderji.com/108211-post7.html

Waiting for your reply

dev mookerji

dev,
please do not conveniently skip the other part of the message. Firstly i am not calling you foolish by any means, if you think i did that, then it is not a question of taking back the words, i can apologize for that.

dev said
http://www.traderji.com/108014-post2.html

oxy
http://www.traderji.com/108025-post4.html

myself
http://www.traderji.com/108144-post6.html

i was only trying to say that a newbie should do what oxy said, try to read all they could get their hands onto before doing anything, trying to emulate a professional during their initial stages is not as easy as it sounds, when i started, i had paid for a subscription and tried to emulate a day trader, he was so quick and sophisticated that i could never enter the trade at his price and never exit at the price he could exit. it did not make my subscription amount from trades. what i wanted to say is "newbie trying to emulate a professional is foolishness"

hari09omkar · #20 18th August 2007, 10:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rajesh.sadhanala

Those just you were highlighting is not returns my dear friend.

You say cup and handle formed in so and so date and ur exit never planned. So how can u claim 42%. That is not a trade setup. Its just like recommendation which will never work in real time environment.

ur profit calculation is simply high and low of some period which is very wrong. Till you dont mention ur exit criteria, ur paper position is also still intact and will affect.

Raj

RAJ,BELIEVE ME I WANTED TO TELL HIM THESE.BUT I DON'T WANTED TO HURT HIM.
ANYWAYS,DEV....PONDER UPON THESE SENTENCES OF RAJESH.AND INSTILL SOME PROFESSIONALISM IN U. "BEAT ME.." TYPE THREADS ARE FAR FROM BEING CLOSE TO PROFESSIONALISM.
READ SOMETHING ABOUT TRADE SET UP,EXITS,AND BACK TESTING SYSTEMS. WITHOUT KNOWING THESE THINGS,YOU ARE GIVING CALLS AFTER CALLS,BUT FOR WHOM? CAN YOU MAKE UR LIVING BY TRADING CONTINUOUSLY,MONTHS AFTER MONTHS? LIKE CREDITVIOLET,UASISH,SAVANT?
FIRSTLY,POST YOUR BACKTESTED SYSTEM RESULTS IN A SEPERATE THREAD.TRADE UR OWN CALLS FOR A YEAR.MAKE 50,000/- TO 1 LAKH IN 1 YEAR.(NO CLASH WITH UR TARGET OF 100%....I THINK THIS IS VERY MUCH REASONABLE TO GET 100% YEARLY.)
THEN TEMPT THE INNOCENT NEWBIES IN TRADING TO TAKE UR CALLS.
SAVANT'S "THREAD ON STOCKS TO KEEP A CLOSE EYE ON" IN TECHNICAL ANALYSIS FORUM IS, AND PREVIOUSLY SAINT'S "NEW INTERMEDIATE UPTREND IN THIS FORUM" WAS, THE BEST TO HAVE A LOOK FOR NEWBIES,WHO DON'T WANT TO TRADE ON THEIR OWN.
AS A FRIEND,I SHOULD APPRECIATE UR CALIBRE AND APPLAUD,BUT AT THE SAME TIME SHOULD RAISE FINGER TO UR MISTAKES WHEN I FEEL.ISN'T IT?
PLEASE DO THE SAME WITH ME WHENEVER U FEEL SO.
LASTLY,I LIKE U AND UR SIMPLICITY DEV,NO CLASH WITH U...JUST A THOUGHT.SO PLEASE DON'T MISUNDERSTAND ME PAL.

Similar Threads for: Trading adivisory...help!
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Real Time Trading Performance! Auto trading on forex	amarnath	Technical Analysis	6	26th June 2007 10:42 AM
Day Trading, Swing Trading and Position Trading	TATrader	Trading on Technicals	9	5th June 2007 01:03 AM
New Trading Systems and Methods (Wiley Trading) by Perry J. Kaufman	bootsum	Books	3	21st April 2007 03:49 PM
Which is best for the pocket?Day-Trading, Futures Trading or Options trading?	EARTHY8	Futures	2	21st March 2007 06:34 PM
Moorat trading: Symbolic start to trading year	Robbie	Current Affairs	0	19th October 2006 03:10 AM