VSA volume spread analysis-more confusion?

[ford7k]

hi friends
TRADEGUIDER
I know some of my friends who followed TRADEGUIDER VSA method and reach no where after over 6 months of dedicatd effort.
It came to light that tradeguider needs one to almost get byheart or remember over 450 rules. A Total Recall moovie runs in your mind.
In he TOTAL RECALL moovie,Arnold goes to mars not as himself but as another person.
Later on he tries to find outt who originally he was.
This has become the state of my friend. he gets wild if i talk of tradeguider.

Anyways,recently there is another fever gripping the traders.
VOLUME SECRET BY NIEGEL HAWKES,of uk.
About this so far no clues. but I received 3 introduction videos.

VSA TRADEGUIDER
VSA NEIGEL HAWKS

Which stone to kill the trader?

if anyone knows the reasons to prefer one of the two,please share

 

[peterpeter]

any one wasted time in VSA or VPA is a fool.

 

[rvlv]

Hawkeye trading system is the way to go(It belongs to Nigel Hawkes).
The system has a sequence to follow
volume-heatmap-trend dots-two level stops.

Unlike tradeguider ,you need not remember 450 rules and become a total recaller.

Hawkeye has most things built in and charting is comfortable.

Anyone who spend 6 months time has some kind of committment-dedication and energy to build concrete evidence if the thing fails or works.
May be he may not be having a guide or mentor to cut short his hardship.
But to call such a hard working guy fool, is just an unpleasant thing.
I am so sorry that some guys dont get result expected inspite of hardwork etc.
Everybody is not lucky to get good guidance early.
please try to be a sympathetic to those who fail in this trading endeavors.