VRAM said:
Is there anybody who makes profit purely thru intra day trading every day and consistently? I am yet to come across such a person. Every body says it is the toughest job. Does it mean that there are no single successful guy who is intra day trading and making a living out of it? Or are there successful peoply but wont reveal the secret? I am perplexed.
Well, I am a daytrader and daytrader by choice as well as compulsion.Though I have yet to achieve significant profits in this arena, I could not resist myself from writing overe here.
Well, day-trading is certainly not a lottery, it involves an armour of skills, tools and most importantly their application. Indicators--Yes, they do work but you need to keep your stop-loss pretty tight. One always need to trade in multiple time frames. Following a stock--Good till it's giving you profits, but till the time daytrading comes handy to you--it's better to avoid changing directions, may hit you hard. One should only change direction when the trend has reversed completely.
Again, in day-trading, if the trader has failed to catch a break-out in the very early stage, he should stay away otherwise he may end up buying/selling in overbought/oversold territory.
News is one area, a day-trader has to be very alert about. But one caveat is--Don't take action on TV/website news--They flash only when the action has taken place, One must watch the technical indicators after hearing the news and act. Rather one classical wisdom is--" Buy on Rumor and sell on News".
Yes, the traditional methods do fail in day-trading or sometimes one is never able to catch the moving fishes. The charting softwares need to be replaced by or assisted by some new breed of softwares which alert the users on parameters like volume break-outs, market makers' moves, Range-bound moves,etc. I am compling a list of items I would like in my software and perhaps 5 yrs down the line, my friends on the forum can use it.
And finally, yes there are traders who are well-off after being fully engaged in day-trading.
Reagrding, the brokers making money from jobbing and day-trading ---- They have a methodology which works for them only is doing what they have been doing for ages--- Playing the spreads. The are still applying the art learned during the historical period of Pit-trading to their benefit. However, it can't work for a trader 'coz of brokerage cost involved. Even the brokers are finding it difficult to sustain the spread play due to increasing transaction costs like stamp duty and STT. And yes, they do overtrade-- A broker will do 400 transactions per day playing the spread but he will never wait for technicals to tell him that the trend is still intact, resistance is at so-n-so level, till the time, market is above so and so level, it's just a correction. He will book loss (a small one), will ride the pullback (make some money over there) and will jump the wagon once again, the trend resumes. And when it comes to returns, if transaction costs are met while playing the spread game, Return on Investment(ROI) is more than what all the other kind of traders/investors can dream about only.
Hope, this is not a bad post.
Best Regards,
--Ashish