Are you profitable in Commodities?

#1
Just an unofficial and unscientific survey.

Please tell us if you are profitable or looser in commodities (only), overall, over at least a one year period (say in tax year 2008, did you make or loose money). To make the survey more useful, everyone should consider answering, not just the money makers.

You may consider giving gain/ loss in terms of percent of your total investment dedicated to commodities only (before paying any taxes but after paying brokerage fees and any other expenses) .

Thank you for taking the time.
 
#2
Just an unofficial and unscientific survey.

Please tell us if you are profitable or looser in commodities (only), overall, over at least a one year period (say in tax year 2008, did you make or loose money). To make the survey more useful, everyone should consider answering, not just the money makers.

You may consider giving gain/ loss in terms of percent of your total investment dedicated to commodities only (before paying any taxes but after paying brokerage fees and any other expenses) .

Thank you for taking the time.
Yes last financial year we made 45% on our capital , this year we are at 20 % profit currently