Sharekhan or Angel..... Plz Plz Plz Help me.

B

babai1012

New Member
#1
#1
Hello friends,
I am new to the world of trading. Please help me.

I want to open a demat account. Which broker to choose??
I've heard Angel's charges are quite low and Sharekhan provide best software for charting. Is it right??

Can i see candlestick chart for intraday trading in angel diet and do they provide real time price quotes??
Does Angel diet provide MACD and other technical indicators??
Which kind of internet connection do i need?? (I'm currently using BSNL CDMA data card which gives a browsing speed of only 128 Kbps)
What is the intraday trading charge in Angel?? (I want to start with low volume)

Forgive me if i have asked too many questions.

Thank you.
 
Last edited:
T

trojan75

New Member
#2
#2
babai1012 said:
Hello friends,
I am new to the world of trading. Please help me.

I want to open a demat account. Which broker to choose??
I've heard Angel's charges are quite low and Sharekhan provide best software for charting. Is it right??

trading charge in Angel?? (I want to start with low volume)

Forgive me if i have asked too many questions.

Thank you.
Click to expand...
No idea about angel but sharekhans trade tiger is the best when it comes to software, if you wanna go for low brokerage then i can vouch for RK global have been using their service for over an yr and pretty satified with their service.I would suggest you to open up with sharekhan and get a hold of the complete system and when ure volumes increase you can switch over to any lower brokerage broker.
 
C

chetanbang

Active Member
#3
#3
In Angel if you give cheque of 1 lakh margin money they will give you 0.1% delivery and 0.01% intraday brokerage irrespective of volumes but they charge minimum brokerage of Rs.30. So even if you day trade for 10,000 rupees you should pay 30 rs, even if you trade for 3 lakh you should pay 30rs.
Yeah, all the technical indicators you mentioned are available in Angel's DietOdin.
 
B

babai1012

New Member
#4
#4
chetanbang said:
In Angel if you give cheque of 1 lakh margin money they will give you 0.1% delivery and 0.01% intraday brokerage irrespective of volumes but they charge minimum brokerage of Rs.30. So even if you day trade for 10,000 rupees you should pay 30 rs, even if you trade for 3 lakh you should pay 30rs.
Yeah, all the technical indicators you mentioned are available in Angel's DietOdin.
Click to expand...
Thank you friend.. :)
 
prst

prst

Well-Known Member
#5
#5
negotiate with them for lowest brokerage rates.

in my personal exp, i had bad experience with angel customer care.

then i shifted to sharekhan, and i find their customer service very prompt and good.

sharekhan gives u margin for T+3 days, and sells off immediately after tat.
but angel gives u more time and charges some interest over that period. (not too sure of this)
 
M

mrkanitkar

Well-Known Member
#6
#6
If you are new to trading, open account with Zerodha or RKG.
There is no point in other brokers, I have accounts with many, it does not help.
Why to pay extra brokerage? Go with flat brokerage.
Now charting, if you are new, first learn tech analysis for 3 months, understand all basic things. Look at historical data. Real time quotes don't make you win in 2 mins. Even if you get realtime quote for charting, you have to give sometime to every stock to react. It's not like I have BMW so, I can run at 300Kms per hr and win race. Typically you need at least 5 min data.

Remember no new money getting generated on NSE/ BSE, its all about taking it from someone.

Take care...
 
Subhadip

Subhadip

Well-Known Member
#7
#7
mrkanitkar said:
If you are new to trading, open account with Zerodha or RKG.
There is no point in other brokers, I have accounts with many, it does not help.
Why to pay extra brokerage? Go with flat brokerage.
Now charting, if you are new, first learn tech analysis for 3 months, understand all basic things. Look at historical data. Real time quotes don't make you win in 2 mins. Even if you get realtime quote for charting, you have to give sometime to every stock to react. It's not like I have BMW so, I can run at 300Kms per hr and win race. Typically you need at least 5 min data.

Remember no new money getting generated on NSE/ BSE, its all about taking it from someone.

Take care...
Click to expand...
this is one of the best reply i have seen ..which is very realistic too..
thank u for helping new comer with really good advice..:clapping::clap::clap::clap:
 
S

sham_share singh

Member
#8
#8
prst said:
negotiate with them for lowest brokerage rates.

in my personal exp, i had bad experience with angel customer care.

then i shifted to sharekhan, and i find their customer service very prompt and good.

sharekhan gives u margin for T+3 days, and sells off immediately after tat.
but angel gives u more time and charges some interest over that period. (not too sure of this)
Click to expand...
Yes, I think Angel gives you margin till T+5 day.(Not sure of this) They charge interest from T+3rd day onwards. Maybe you should ask your RM about this.
 
K

kaly422000

Well-Known Member
#9
#9
angel odin and sharekhan software r good source of data for real time charting in amibroker with some realtime software .
other wise as a broker they r bit costly for new comer.
but if u want to learn and can go for rs 400+ amc charge then u can go to sharekhan.
 
K

Khushijain

Member
#10
#10
Hi babai1012,
I am a broker of kotak securities,we provide a good software to trade hassle free and since kotak has its own bank account the visiblity is better for your money. Our customer service it one of the best in the industry and we even provide professional help to increase your profits.
my email id is [email protected] mail me if your interested.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
pulkit55 ULTIMATE Final Comparison (Angel Broking vs Sharekhan) Brokers & Trading Platforms 4
K tell me which terminal is best sharekhan's tradetiger or angel broking's odin diet Brokers & Trading Platforms 1
S HDFC vs Angel vs Sharekhan Beginners Guide 1
manish1247 sharekhan vs angel Beginners Guide 41
P Calling All users of Angel Broking / Sharekhan / Indiabulls... Brokers & Trading Platforms 107

Similar threads