Zerodha....

bk.shares · #11 22nd October 2010, 04:20 PM

thats good.for fno traders

TradeRaid · #12 22nd October 2010, 04:22 PM

Even I'm a trader who has been flipping around trying to find the right broker. Everything sounds good about them, but only trying it out will give us clear info.

By the way, isn't there SEBI to make sure that our funds are safe? Personally, I don't think going to any broker should be a risk... The real risk is in the markets.

TradeRaid · #13 22nd October 2010, 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MindlessTrader

if trade executed in one go only then its good...otherwise mostly trade executed in parts..so Rs 20 for every execution may not be a good idea...then...

I have confirmed with them... The charge is Rs 20 per 'ORDER' placement, not per order execution... which means that we will pay only Rs 20, irrespective of when our orders get executed, and irrespective of the size of our orders. Sounds unbelievable... but it is true.

sanjayspeilberg · #14 22nd October 2010, 04:45 PM

so guys which is better?? R.K. Global or Zerodha??

since am new to futures trading,am not gonna trade in many lots. I just gonna trade with 1 lot.

in this case, can i go for R.K. GLobal which charges Rs.9 per lot
or
Zerodha which charges Rs.20 per trade.

godisbogus · #15 22nd October 2010, 04:50 PM

Simply Go for RKGLOBAL. He charges just Rs.9/- per lot each side. Nobody can beat him both in brokerage and service. Dietodin terminal is superb, it works nonstop. No hidden charges. Financial Ledger is very easy to understand. What more you want boss?

sanjayspeilberg · #16 22nd October 2010, 05:02 PM

zerodha charges:

Account opening fee--Rs.600
AMC--Rs.400
Brokerage-Rs.20 per trade.

R.K.Global Charges:

Account opening fee--Rs.200
Monthly maintenance Charge for web based platform--Rs.99*
Brokerage--Rs.9 per lot.

in R.K. Global we need to pay the maintenance fee every month but we dont need to pay any in Zerodha.

only thing am concerned is many users in this forum have reported that they have problem with trading platform of R.K global.

could some one pls guide me in this

TradeRaid · #17 22nd October 2010, 05:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sanjayspeilberg

so guys which is better?? R.K. Global or Zerodha??

since am new to futures trading,am not gonna trade in many lots. I just gonna trade with 1 lot.

in this case, can i go for R.K. GLobal which charges Rs.9 per lot
or
Zerodha which charges Rs.20 per trade.

I think if you're trading with one lot, it's best to trade with RKG. However, if you increase your trade size, then Zerodha seems to be a good bet.

godisbogus · #18 22nd October 2010, 05:29 PM

I am trading with RKGLOBAL since six months. I have three accounts. All diet odins. Upto this day i have not faced any problem with the trading platform. I am a full time professional trader. I am using online terminals since 2000 march. But RKGLOBAL is the best. I trade minimum 10 lots per day in each account.

smartboy1jan1982 · #19 22nd October 2010, 05:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TradeRaid

Even I'm a trader who has been flipping around trying to find the right broker. Everything sounds good about them, but only trying it out will give us clear info.

By the way, isn't there SEBI to make sure that our funds are safe? Personally, I don't think going to any broker should be a risk... The real risk is in the markets.

There is a slight risk of misconduct, fraud by the brokerage firm. There can be many malpractices and shady activities going on there of which we may no knowledge. SEBI and other govt. agencies can only take action against them after they have done anything wrong but they can not prevent them from doing any wrong.

smartboy1jan1982 · #20 22nd October 2010, 05:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TradeRaid

I have confirmed with them... The charge is Rs 20 per 'ORDER' placement, not per order execution... which means that we will pay only Rs 20, irrespective of when our orders get executed, and irrespective of the size of our orders. Sounds unbelievable... but it is true.

What about Order modification? many times I modify my limit order's price in a day. will it be also charged like a new Order?

The Following User Says Thank You to TradeRaid For This Useful Post:
MindlessTrader (22nd October 2010)

The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to TradeRaid For This Useful Post:
alroyraj (22nd October 2010), biyasc (22nd October 2010), comm4300 (22nd October 2010), MindlessTrader (22nd October 2010), murthymsr (30th October 2010)

The Following User Says Thank You to sanjayspeilberg For This Useful Post:
sanamtrade (19th November 2010)

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to godisbogus For This Useful Post:
kalllu (6th November 2010), MindlessTrader (22nd October 2010), sanamtrade (19th November 2010)

The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to godisbogus For This Useful Post:
MindlessTrader (22nd October 2010), naveenvadavadagi (5th December 2010), sanamtrade (19th November 2010), Sunny1 (22nd October 2010)

The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to smartboy1jan1982 For This Useful Post:
MindlessTrader (22nd October 2010), murthymsr (30th October 2010), sanamtrade (19th November 2010)