Choose your Broker

Sunny1 · #1 9th May 2009, 10:55 PM

Hi everybody. I have searched a lot in this forum about the brokers and this was really headache as there are lot of threads and all scattered therefore having difficult to choose a broker. And there is no information available for lot of brokers like canmoney arthmoney navia.In this thread I will try to list almost all the broking firms and thier brokerage along with features & thier trading platform and important user reviews from various sites. this is very long and tedious process therefore I need your help too to complete this process. I will update this thread whenever I can so plz be patient
Thanks.

At first I will start listing name of all broking firms then their brokerage(if available) and so on. you can also post information about broking firms and I will copy & paste it into the main post of that broking firm.It become easy for us compare various broking firms and choose accordingly and that too in one single thread.
Please post any advice, suggestion, comment or anything.

Here we go
1.16anna
2.5paisa (india infoline )
3.Angle Broking
4.Arthmoney
5.canmoney
6.Geojit
7.Hdfc
8.Icicidirect
9.idbi paisabuilder
10.Tata securities (This is one rare as no one knows)
11.Indiabulls
12.Just Trade (Bajaj)
13.Karvy broking
14.Kotak
15.Motilal oswal
16.Navia Market
17.Networth Stock Broking Limited (NSBL)
18.Reliance Money
19.Religare
20.RK global
21.SBI 3 in 1
22.sharekhan
23.UTI Securities Ltd
24.ventura-securities

The above has covered almost all the major broking firms. If anything left please let me know.
After I will start posting about brokerage charges and all that

There are number of other broking firms which I have not list becuase they are not necessary and also list will become too large.

sush21 · #2 9th May 2009, 11:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sunny1

Hi everybody. I have searched a lot in this forum about the brokers and this was really headache as there are lot of threads and all scattered therefore having difficult to choose a broker. And there is no information available for lot of brokers like canmoney arthmoney navia.In this thread I will try to list almost all the broking firms and thier brokerage along with features & thier trading platform and important user reviews from various sites. this is very long and tedious process therefore I need your help too to complete this process. I will update this thread whenever I can so plz be patient
Thanks.

At first I will start listing name of all broking firms then their brokerage(if available) and so on. you can also post information about broking firms and I will copy & paste it into the main post of that broking firm.It become easy for us compare various broking firms and choose accordingly and that too in one single thread.
Please post any advice, suggestion, comment or anything.

http://www.traderji.com/brokers-dema...vs-5paise.html

Sunny1 · #3 9th May 2009, 11:43 PM

I have browsed all thread on this topic in this. plz read post properly
that thread does not contain all the information also we have to searched here there. does not have information on canmoney, arthmoney, navia market and many other

harshatmehta · #4 17th July 2009, 10:39 PM

For Justtrade (Bajaj) charges are .03 on both legs intraday and .30 on both legs for delivery + rs.23 delivery charge!

Service bad.

If everyone post about the brokerages then it will be useful to everyone. Me too searched for a long time but not able to find many.

Sunny1 · #5 17th July 2009, 10:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by harshatmehta

For Justtrade (Bajaj) charges are .03 on both legs intraday and .30 on both legs for delivery + rs.23 delivery charge!

Service bad.

If everyone post about the brokerages then it will be useful to everyone. Me too searched for a long time but not able to find many.

Thanks. I have delayed this project due to less response. To be cont...

murthymsr · #6 18th July 2009, 06:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sunny1

Thanks. I have delayed this project due to less response. To be cont...

Thanks sunny, for the good initiative.

I feel that:

1) Popular brokers be picked up first as lot of information is already available in this site and a few other places and the same may be compiled and presented.

2) Other brokers may be added later.

3) The data finally be able to be presented in a tabular form for easy comparison of brokers against different parameters.

4) The tabulation may just give information allowing users to compare for themselves and decide what is best for them rather than just giving ranks/stars.

5) Qualitative comparison can be made only by one who has experienced all/many brokers for a sufficient length of time.

Hope you agree.

All the best.

murthymsr

Sunny1 · #7 18th July 2009, 09:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by murthymsr

Thanks sunny, for the good initiative.

I feel that:

1) Popular brokers be picked up first as lot of information is already available in this site and a few other places and the same may be compiled and presented.

2) Other brokers may be added later.

3) The data finally be able to be presented in a tabular form for easy comparison of brokers against different parameters.

4) The tabulation may just give information allowing users to compare for themselves and decide what is best for them rather than just giving ranks/stars.

5) Qualitative comparison can be made only by one who has experienced all/many brokers for a sufficient length of time.

Hope you agree.

All the best.

murthymsr

Thanks.
Points are perfectly matching with my thoughts. I was just thinking what should be the format of table.

PGDIMES · #8 19th July 2009, 12:01 AM

Do it quickly so that Ican apply for a suitable broker in a week's time.

Sunny1 · #9 31st July 2009, 01:01 AM

Hi guys . m making the table to list all the brokers along with charges and reviews.
just tell me the what catagories should be included like brokerage , charges , service, platform, most common user complaints etc.

The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to harshatmehta For This Useful Post:
biggles (17th July 2009), Sunny1 (17th July 2009)