Axis Bank 3-in-1 account

Which is the best brokerage firm?


  • Total voters
    91
#21
Thank You so much for sharing your feedback on Axis 3-in-1 account. I have opened a Savings a/c but yet to get my account number. As soon as I get it, I'll go for the Demat & Trading a/c. So should I open the trading stuff only when the market is open? I mean, your friend who followed the instruction and waited till Monday, got his account locked?




We recently subscribed to Axis-bank 3-in-1 account.

First the positive :) observations:

The account works with Mozilla and Firefox browsers on Linux machines. Many other trading accounts work only with the lame duck Internet Explorer from Microsoft. Refusal to work with Firefox is an indication of non-standard web interfaces and web services. It indicates that the software vendor has willfully or accidentally locked the trading platform provider to a maimed software and the platform provider could not realize the trap.

The power of attorney conditions on the funds and demat accounts are reasonable unlike the unacceptable 'signed blank cheque' type of PoAs peddled by some others.

Few negative :( observations:

The online tutorials on how to buy-and-sell etc are reasonable, but they are not in phase with the currently deployed interfaces. For example, I could not find the instruction to block the funds when placing a buy-order in the buy-sell tutorial.

The software interfaces and logic for many processes are dependent on whether you login during the trading hours or otherwise. Many functionalities have been assigned to the trading period arbitrarily. For example, the first time login is supposed to force you to change the initial password (given to you in a sealed envelope) to something new. Unfortunately, this check is done only if you log in during the trading hours. My friend was told that he should not login for the first time during a Saturday because he might risk getting his account locked. We did not know this and logged in on a Saturday. The system did not ask for change of password and allowed us to do all the things possible on a saturday. We wanted to change the password ourselves but the option was not available in the non-trading period! We had to wait till Monday to change the password. Luckily it did not lock our account but my friend who waited till Monday somehow managed to lock his!

Probably geogit will have to refactor the features of their software and decouple them from unnecessary linkages to trading and non-trading hours.
 
#23
I think you are talking about UTISEL which has now a new name USECTRADE.
I am not sure about it being sold to STA CHART.
Are you sure?
Please visit this website :
http://www.standardchartered.com/media-centre/press-releases/2007/documents/grp_20070822.pdf

Standard Chartered to acquire 49% stake in UTI Securities from
Securities Trading Corporation of India
Standard Chartered retains option to buy 100% in UTI Securities by 2010
London, August 23, 2007: Securities Trading Corporation of India Limited (STCI) and
Standard Chartered PLC have today entered into a strategic partnership for Standard
Chartered to acquire a 49 per cent stake in UTI Securities Limited, a leading Indian brokerage
house, for approximately USD 36 million cash. STCI currently owns 100 per cent of UTI
Securities, having acquired it in 2006 from the Administrator of the Specified Undertaking of
the Unit Trust of India.
Under the agreement, the parties have provided for necessary options to raise Standard
Chartereds stake in stages to 100 per cent by 2010, subject to necessary regulatory
approvals.
Jaspal Bindra, Director, Standard Chartered Bank, said: This investment is ground-breaking
for the Group as it signals entry into securities broking and I am glad it commences with India.
I see great potential for this business through this strategic partnership.
Neeraj Swaroop, CEO India, Standard Chartered Bank, said: This investment underlines
Standard Chartereds commitment to grow in India. We are delighted at this opportunity of
partnering with STCI in growing UTI Securities. The company has a good franchise and a
professional management team.
The partnership will enable Standard Chartered to broaden its product offering in Wealth
Management and Private Banking within India, and the non-resident Indian (NRI) product
portfolio in our footprint countries, Mr Swaroop added.
G Narayanan, Managing Director, Securities Trading Corporation of India, said: We welcome
Standard Chartered as a strategic investor in UTI Securities. We believe that Standard
Chartered, with its long track record in India, a large client base and extensive overseas
presence will add significant value to UTI Securities.
UTI Securities, set up in 1994, has grown from an institutional brokerage house to a fullfledged
financial intermediary having nationwide presence in 60 major Indian cities with 41
branches and 174 franchises to service a wide range of clients. The company has significant
presence in institutional and retail broking, online trading (www.usectrade.com), depository
services, portfolio management services, equities research, investment banking, fixed income
securities, and distribution of third-party financial products.
 
#24
Geojit you will not have the option to add the watch list unless you have premium account or you trade in such a way that the brokerage is above Rs300.
 
#25
Coolcritic, can you again quote all the charges you are getting with Axis
Today I talked with them they are telling 0.55% on delivery and 0.10 on ID.
Fut 0.05 on each leg
Options 2.5% or min 100 per leg.
 
#26
Schedule of charges:
Below Rs. 10lacs: 0.55%
10lacs-30lacs: 0.50%
30lacs-75lacs: 0.40%
75lacs-2crore: 0.20%
Above 2crore: 0.15%

Minimum brokerage Rs. 20 or 2.5% of trade value, whichever is lower (Here obviously Rs. 20 is lower as minimum of Rs. 1000 has to be traded, 2.5% of which comes to Rs. 25)

Intraday: 0.10% for each leg of transaction
Service Tax: 12.36%of brokerage
STT: 0.10% delivery Cash segment
0.02% Intra-day Cash segment

20 free calls/month. Additional Rs. 20/call

Actually the 0.33% that I quoted previously was told by an Axis Bank employee but today I had gone to thebranch to take a detailed sheet of charges.



Coolcritic, can you again quote all the charges you are getting with Axis
Today I talked with them they are telling 0.55% on delivery and 0.10 on ID.
Fut 0.05 on each leg
Options 2.5% or min 100 per leg.
 
#27
mr coolcritic, i have some doubt pls clear it.


1. geojit offer 0.03% bokerage for intraday and .030% for delivery.
but ur data was not match this.


2. us wrote 20 free calls/month. Additional Rs. 20/call

here what u mean by calls.


3.what is the account opening charge and amc charge.

4. which website we trade whether geojit website or uti website.

5. what trading terminal they use odin or other


pls answe my questions.
iam also interested in opening the acount

4.
 
#28
mr coolcritic, i have some doubt pls clear it.


1. geojit offer 0.03% bokerage for intraday and .030% for delivery.
but ur data was not match this.


2. us wrote 20 free calls/month. Additional Rs. 20/call

here what u mean by calls.


3.what is the account opening charge and amc charge.

4. which website we trade whether geojit website or uti website.

5. what trading terminal they use odin or other


pls answe my questions.
iam also interested in opening the acount

4.
Hi,
I would also be intrested in finding out from you what your experience has been.

Thank you,

Amiava
 
#29
Hi! The charges that I mentioned just a few posts ago are the ones levied by Geojit. Your data says that for both intraday and delivery, its 0.03% which is impossible!

As far as the calls go, I have no clue of it since I don't call them. I trade using my computer at home.

The account opening charges are Rs. 500, and annual maintenance Rs. 250.

They use the Geojit website for trading purposes, not the UTI website, and they use ODIN terminal.

Hope this clarifies your doubts. Get back to me if you need any further clarifications.

-Ali.


P.S. I have been using Geojit since the past month and a half, and their service has been satisfactory, but if you are more into Intraday, then this is not for you. This is good for investors. As said, they charge a minimum brokerage of Rs. 20. So if you transact for an amount of Rs.10000, then 0.1% comes to Rs.10, but they would charge you Rs.20, plus ST, STT. Also, for transactions of a lesser amount, you would run into losses unless the scrip you have selected, shoots up on a given day, like it happened with JP Associates on Monday and yesterday. So go through all the pros and cons of Geojit.
 

TFL

Well-Known Member
#30
Hi members

I had read a lot about the positive and negative sides of Reliance Money, ICICI and other brokerage firms out here. I visited some of the offices of firms like RMoney, Sharekhan, Indiabulls, Angel Broking, etc. Now I have taken the decision to open a 3-in-1 account with Axis Bank.

May I please have the opinion of experienced members who are dealing with the bank?

Thanx a ton...
Dear coolcritic007,

My hearty advise is not to go with Axis Bank 3 in One account(As they are advertised.).
I took one a month ago and really its not a 3 in one account. Axis bank is only providing an account to receive or transfer fund to Geojit. You will get no assistance from axis bank regarding your trading/demat or anythings. They will just act as a normal banking firm. The customer care of axis bank is pathetic.

One more thing. Axis banks A/C or transaction related Security is very questionable.

Geojit's brokerages are low but you will miss a lot...really a lot in Geojit than others. Even you cannot use your shares directly for margin. For this you need to manually(paper application) pledge or de-pledge by going to their office. Linking other banks(HDFC, or so) with Geojit will be a better solution if you need Geojit as broker.

Sharekhan, ICICIDirect are much better than the said Axis Banks 3(ha hah ah... :) ) in one

Currently I have active a/cs with Geojit, Sharekhan, ICICIDirect.

If you need any details from my experience you may contact me here itself.

Haribird.