Sorry read many parts of forum but unable to decide which broker.

kingsmasher1

Well-Known Member
#31
If you know how to trade, go with Sharekhan. I have been using their Tradetiger for sometime, and it's really awesome.

Don't worry about brokerage, if you are a regular trader, they may reduce your brokerage on request.

AVOID ANGEL BROKING, they are the worst type and horrible customer service.
I was unable to tolerate them, even for a month.

Or if you are new to trading, and learner type, go with some discount broker. I have opened an account with Zerodha recently, but yet to trade with them though (still experimenting their platform with my login) so can't comment about them, but yes - their kite platform looks cool.
 
#32
If you know how to trade, go with Sharekhan. I have been using their Tradetiger for sometime, and it's really awesome.

Don't worry about brokerage, if you are a regular trader, they may reduce your brokerage on request.

AVOID ANGEL BROKING, they are the worst type and horrible customer service.
I was unable to tolerate them, even for a month.

Or if you are new to trading, and learner type, go with some discount broker. I have opened an account with Zerodha recently, but yet to trade with them though (still experimenting their platform with my login) so can't comment about them, but yes - their kite platform looks cool.
I have done my trades with kotak offline, online- karvy, India Bulls, Shae Khan, R K Global, Angel in client account (worst), India infoline so far remember client account,Now Finvasia. Trade Tiger is ok but in volatility time it hangs or price was delayed. They are very arrogant. My daily brokerage when I as with R K global be Rs 2000-3000 which you can imgaine with Share Khan 0.01%. Now I dont need to pay brokerage at all. I have to check whether They charging Rs 150 per month or not. Now huge saving. Now a days I change my way of trading but earlier I use to scalp 50-100lots mega in RKG. Hope you understand how much saving for me. Nest is not good software as odin is but ok as Now I am using elliot wave. I have paid charting as well as free real time software too. My trade are based on comex, nymex in commodities. I mean trends. Trade tiger is good for them who dont have any other software for charging. I am happy with finvasia. No issues yet. Once penalty issue that was clear and genuine.I dont need margin more then 2x intraday as that doomed me earlier. Now successful enjoying my profit.
 

kaly422000

Well-Known Member
#33
Hi
@Thread Starter,

If you simply want or can trade in Nest Trader or Nse Now and want the lowest brokerage in the market with best service, Go for SASONLINE. And if you wish to have trading plate-farms like Nest Trader, PI or kite go for ZERODHA. KITE and PI are the best trading platefarms i have ever used. If you trade on cash segment with delivery Zerodha don't charge any brokerage.

There are several things I like about both of these brokers.
1. KITE's charts are superb believe me i forgot even Amibroker which is the best charting software in the market.

Go and explore yourself hope you will like both the brokers.
what is the minimum system requirement for zerodha nest trader and pi. do pi have cover order. i have pentium dual core with 2gb ram bought on 2011
 

kaly422000

Well-Known Member
#34
I have done my trades with kotak offline, online- karvy, India Bulls, Shae Khan, R K Global, Angel in client account (worst), India infoline so far remember client account,Now Finvasia. Trade Tiger is ok but in volatility time it hangs or price was delayed. They are very arrogant. My daily brokerage when I as with R K global be Rs 2000-3000 which you can imgaine with Share Khan 0.01%. Now I dont need to pay brokerage at all. I have to check whether They charging Rs 150 per month or not. Now huge saving. Now a days I change my way of trading but earlier I use to scalp 50-100lots mega in RKG. Hope you understand how much saving for me. Nest is not good software as odin is but ok as Now I am using elliot wave. I have paid charting as well as free real time software too. My trade are based on comex, nymex in commodities. I mean trends. Trade tiger is good for them who dont have any other software for charging. I am happy with finvasia. No issues yet. Once penalty issue that was clear and genuine.I dont need margin more then 2x intraday as that doomed me earlier. Now successful enjoying my profit.
as per odin, for latest odin many offline brokers charges for rs 250/ month or so. i have installed one odin (version 10.0.2.0). not tested with user id and password. is this version better than nest trader. probably this odin dont have cover order etc. but for latest nest trader i heard that minimum system required is pentium core i3 and 4gb ram. but i have dual core pentium and 2gb ram in one system and 4 gb in other system. so what platform sud i select . odin or nestrader? pls suggest on the criteria of different order type option and smooth running as i think ur experienced enough. thanx in advance
 
#35
as per odin, for latest odin many offline brokers charges for rs 250/ month or so. i have installed one odin (version 10.0.2.0). not tested with user id and password. is this version better than nest trader. probably this odin dont have cover order etc. but for latest nest trader i heard that minimum system required is pentium core i3 and 4gb ram. but i have dual core pentium and 2gb ram in one system and 4 gb in other system. so what platform sud i select . odin or nestrader? pls suggest on the criteria of different order type option and smooth running as i think ur experienced enough. thanx in advance
if you are scalper and fast trader use odin. Else nest trader ok.As nest trader disconnect many times for few seconds. If I had a choice I will definitely go for odin for trading in two.
 
#36
Hi Guys, sorry to disturb you. I want to open account with one discount broker but unable to judge.I am posting my criteria-

1) Reliable and supportive as we all want.

2) Right now planning to use smallest lot of gold 100 lot 1000 lot at different places.But this become expensive as flat brokerage.I can trade mini also 10 times but I decided lowest petal because I want to trade reversals and swing.

3) Good trading terminal which cannot hang at the time of volatility.

4) I dont need any charting support as already has my paid software.

5)If there is trailing sl option that will be great.

6) Any bank through neft for deposit and withdrawal no issues.

7)Leverage 3X or above fine.Though no plan for using leverage fully but avail for 1 lot. Every week I increase 1 lot gold mini lot or 100 gold petals specially on every 5 successful trade for 100 points on an daily basis average.

Please suggest.
Few in mind-
1) Zerodha- currently read some issues with terminal and client support.
2)Rksv- Felt good just need to know about their terminal and support
3)Rk global - earlier was there. good experience but not suitable for mini lots.
4) Achiivers thinking of shifting later but dont know their support and terminal part. They are asking for Rs 750 one time fee. So till I dont increase my capital I will not. If others are like this also unlimited plan then no issues too. But this time I dont want to scalp but i want to take swing of minimum 100-200 points.
many more I read but please suggest with your experience if more than 3 months. Please only client I means end user suggest so that I can decide with more confidence. As I am always scared not because of my own trade but only have worries about broker part about support/terminal.
Thanz.
Why don't you give it a shot to FYERS?
There's a lot of hype about their trading platforms because they got TradingView charts in India free of charge. I felt the platforms are decently well and equipped with good screeners. They also have something called the 30 Day Challenge which refunds back your entire brokerage if you win. I know this all because I won that challenge once.
 

Similar threads