ShareKhan Vs IndiaBulls?

trader31339 · #11 24th August 2006, 11:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fullyaddicted

hi

I will not doing off market trading mostly. So is it good for me to go with indiabulls than sharekhan b'coz of their nice application they provide and less brokerage?

HAHA ,
no one is trading offline here, everyone is trading online.
But in case of problems like power failure, internet DC , when u wont be able to sq off ur positions online, place fresh orders online what will u do? U have to call them.

Thus, even if you are trading online you should also consider the offline system of the broker so that incase you are unable to log in to the system due to any reason you can still trade actively without any hassle

trader31339 · #12 24th August 2006, 11:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sivavkm

Dear trader31339,

Really informative and will be useful to many.

Also, can you please provide a comparison about their trading application platforms - like its features/charting/execution speed/auto-square-off/...? Is it web-based/software-based OR...? Is there any monthly volume/brokerage commitment ? Any other charges like annual software fees/ maintanance fees etc? Based on PIB intraday data, some of our members (satya, pagenotfound...) developed some softwares also, but nothing for sharekhan

Thanks & Regards
Siva

Trading applications are best of both.
Indiabulls dont have any charges which i have already told in my post.Sharekhan do have for exe based software.

unicorn · #13 24th August 2006, 11:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trader31339

Trading applications are best of both.
Indiabulls dont have any charges which i have already told in my post.Sharekhan do have for exe based software.

Hi
Both Indiabulls and Sharekhan Trading software's are slow reguarding order execution.The software's are slow in order execution compared to ODIN Diet.

trader31339 · #14 24th August 2006, 06:38 PM

orders are directly routed to the exchange just like odin, so there is no point in saying that they are slow compared to odin...anyways individual exp may be bhin bhin

unicorn · #15 24th August 2006, 07:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by trader31339

orders are directly routed to the exchange just like odin, so there is no point in saying that they are slow compared to odin...anyways individual exp may be bhin bhin

Hi
No Never , ODIN Diet has the capability to sent the orders directly to the exchange.But in Sharekhan's and Indiabulls software order's are sent to the exchange Via The Broker.Order routing is not the same.First trade on the Three Softwares ODIN Diet , Indiabulls & sharekhan and then make comments.

amit0014628_am · #16 24th August 2006, 08:50 PM

hi,
i am trading through sharekhan speed trade plus .
brokerage rates for intraday trading in cash are as follows,
buy 0.10%
sell 0.10%
both for intraday only not for delivery trades.
If we add service tax, stt, turnover tax, stamp duty to above brokerage rates
the cost of a trade is
0.10% + 0.10% + 0.06% =0.26% approximately, for cash.
it means that if you bought a share of Rs.100/- then the cost is 0.26% i.e. 0.26 paise. No Profit No Loss (NPNL) =100 + 0.26 =100.26
My request for all day traders from all brokerage houses is to quote the cost of a trade like above.
So that we can find out which is the cheapest brokerage house for INTRADAY TRADING

Please respond all TRADERJI.
happy trading.

fullyaddicted · #17 24th August 2006, 09:00 PM

Hi

Thanks for the info amit. Could you give me the same for Indiabulls?

amit0014628_am · #18 24th August 2006, 09:10 PM

#17 Today, 09:00 PM
fullyaddicted
Junior Member Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 12

Re: ShareKhan Vs IndiaBulls?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hi

Thanks for the info amit. Could you give me the same for Indiabulls

Well i am interested in finding out the cheapest brokerage house for DAY TRADING.
I am only having info about SHERU . That's why i want to know about all the brokerage houses.

Thanks

trader31339 · #19 25th August 2006, 10:21 AM

amit0014628,
How fast it payout amit with sharekhan right now?

Incase if you give a withdrawal request today how much time does it takes to recieve the fund sin your bank account?

trader31339 · #20 25th August 2006, 10:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by unicorn

Hi
No Never , ODIN Diet has the capability to sent the orders directly to the exchange.But in Sharekhan's and Indiabulls software order's are sent to the exchange Via The Broker.Order routing is not the same.First trade on the Three Softwares ODIN Diet , Indiabulls & sharekhan and then make comments.

unicorn,
I have used all three .
Earlier speedtrade software of sharekhan was not routing orders directly to exchange infact it used to route through brokers server.
But right now the software routes the orders directly to exchange. You better check your self. You are talking abt the earlier version.

PIB of indiabulls routes the orders directly to exchange right from its launch.

View Poll Results: ShareKhan Vs IndiaBulls
ShareKhan	7	38.89%
IndiaBulls	6	33.33%
Both Sucks	5	27.78%
Voters: 18. You may not vote on this poll

Similar Threads for: ShareKhan Vs IndiaBulls?
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Confused - Sharekhan vs Icicidirect vs Hdfc vs Kotak vs Indiabulls vs 5paise	sunandoghosh	Brokers & Demat Matters	699	30th November 2008 07:14 PM
5Paisa.com or Sharekhan or IndiaBulls	hometypist	Brokers & Demat Matters	88	11th September 2008 12:50 AM
NSE or BSE? 5Paisa/Sharekhan or indiabulls? NSE-Quotetracker?	Sanjay123	Brokers & Demat Matters	3	19th January 2008 06:33 PM
sharekhan	sgkalai	Brokers & Demat Matters	16	8th August 2007 03:19 PM