Indian Stock Brokers - Geojit.com

nirmaljain · #11 10th August 2004, 11:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by amc

I have a similiar problem with icicidirect.com.

The website gets to load terribly slowly on high traffic hours/days.

This happens in the opening and closing hours of trade and on Mondays and Fridays.

Otherwise I think the 3 in 1 account is great in terms of convenience although they charge a high delivery brokerage (one way) of 0.85% an stock trades.

How much do you pay 5paisa.com? Is it 0.05% on delivery trades??

sorry for the delay. the brokerage is 0.05% for square off one way and 0.25% for delivery + taxes etc.

girishammanagi · #12 11th August 2004, 04:39 PM

Hi All,
I too have had bad experience with icicidirect.com, especially mornings. If I place the buy/sell order just before the market starts, they keep on the showing the order status as "queued" almost for an hour. This has happened to me many times.
And if you're in hurry sell or buy something, it shows up problems like where you cannot allocate funds using "modify allocation", sometimes demat balance is not shown, etc., etc.
Complaing to them has never helped.
Even I would like to switch to some other account, please let me who's the best in India.

Thanks,
-Girish

arun · #13 11th August 2004, 05:49 PM

From what I have heard Refco SIfy is pretty good, although they do not have the demat and savings account linked to the trading account like icici.

nareshch · #14 21st August 2004, 02:15 PM

Hi ,

I am also an ex- user of icicidirct.com .After much frustation with their service i opted for Indiabulls . In almost all aspects Indiabulls is far better than icicidirect.com . As of now i am paying brokerage of .05% all inclusive on each side for squared off trades and 0.34% for delivary .The speed of the site or their interface is good .

Quote:

Originally Posted by nirmaljain

sorry for the delay. the brokerage is 0.05% for square off one way and 0.25% for delivery + taxes etc.

I read some where that the minimum brokerage 5paisa charges is 5 paisa per share what ever your buying cost is .If that is correct you might be paying high brokerage for low priced stocks .Please confirm that whether 5 paisa is charging minimum brokerage per share of 5 paisa .

regards
Naresh

nareshch · #15 21st August 2004, 02:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nirmaljain

sorry for the delay. the brokerage is 0.05% for square off one way and 0.25% for delivery + taxes etc.

Hi ,

http://www.5paisa.com/products/5plt.html

If the brokearge is subject to a minimum of 5paisa per share then it will be too high on the shares of value less than 100/-

As my english is poor , i will just tell you what i am thinking

If you buy shares of essar steel . the current price of a share is Rs25.80/-

If you pay a brokerage of 5 paisa per share , then the brokerage would be
0.194%

So please confirm whether the following rule is still apllicabl in 5 paisa .
""Brokerage is 0.05% or 5Paisa per Rs.100 for trading turnover, subject to a minimum of 5Paisa per share and Rs25/- per contract regardless of number of transactions""

regards
Naresh

ROSAMMA SEBASTIN · #16 5th January 2005, 01:27 PM

Hello, I am Mrs.Rosamma Sebastian. I would like know more about you and like to trade with you. Please help me since I am quite new in this field. Thank you.

heda_p · #17 14th January 2005, 11:32 PM

aaded to what is mentioned already...

icicidirect is not showing live quotes...is there any other trading website 5paisa/sharekhan/kotakstreet or anything else which does that?

i know 5 paisa allow trading in bse shares does it allow to trade in all the bse scripts or selected ones? sharekhan and koptak dosn't allow trading in bse....

so live quotes and bse trading should also be consideredv before taking a new account

Neal · #18 15th January 2005, 12:25 PM

Considering the pathetic internet infrastructure setup, I doubt if one will ever get live quotes on their PC.

Unless you are right at the brokers terminal, of course.

mintu · #19 22nd January 2005, 10:47 AM

dear all

i am using for last 11 months 5paisa.com is the best site for on line trading after improvement in his server capacity from last one month my trading terminal runs so fine
and his intraday tips are excilent if you are looking for the best trading terminal in india try 5paisa.com trader terminal
regards

mintu

Similar Threads for: Indian Stock Brokers - Geojit.com
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Indian Stock Markets	hometypist	Equities	9	16th January 2008 05:37 PM
The Deadly Art Of Stock Manipulation Pt1	Joeblack	Trading Psychology	28	29th July 2007 09:13 AM
Is the Indian Investor afraid of investing in the stock markets?	TATrader	Current Affairs	0	2nd December 2004 03:37 PM
Monsoon & trends of the Indian Stock Market	Neal	General Trading & Investing Chat	2	17th July 2004 07:07 PM
Indian stock market at 1-month low on pre-budget nerves	TATrader	Current Affairs	0	23rd June 2004 07:26 PM