I want review on ashwani gujral new book

fire_gun · #1 7th July 2008, 10:52 AM

i want to know how many of you read ashwani gujral new book"how to make money with trading charts" which has been released in last week.....i want to know did u found anything interesting and new about it???...i didn;t got copy of book because in my town because it is still unavailable so iam looking for review before purchasing it.....plz comment and tell me is it worth to read????

XRAY27 · #2 7th July 2008, 12:11 PM

i have gone through this books this books explains technicals with ease
and also last chapter of money management is very good
usefull for new people who wants to learn technicals.... not for senior,,,,,,,

fire_gun · #3 7th July 2008, 01:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by XRAY27

i have gone through this books this books explains technicals with ease
and also last chapter of money management is very good
usefull for new people who wants to learn technicals.... not for senior,,,,,,,

ok thanks for replying... tell me is the book is about same type of basic patterns{h&s,wedges flag peanuts} or less gloryfied charts pattrens r also explained??? first book{how to make money with derivatives} also contain money management in last chapter.. r u sure na that u read new book?

big_bull · #4 9th July 2008, 08:17 AM

could u please tell me from which publication this book is available. Is it good for starters,who doesn't know anything about technical analysis OR starting with "Technical Analysis of Stock Trends BY Robert D. Edwards & John Magee" will be better.
Please suggest. Thanks....

fire_gun · #5 9th July 2008, 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by big_bull

could u please tell me from which publication this book is available. Is it good for starters,who doesn't know anything about technical analysis OR starting with "Technical Analysis of Stock Trends BY Robert D. Edwards & John Magee" will be better.
Please suggest. Thanks....

first book of ashwani gujral{how to make money with trading derivatives} is very helpful for starters..it include some simple trading ideas ,charts and basic knowledge of technical oscillators and last chapter of money management is most important lesson........

uasish · #6 10th July 2008, 09:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by big_bull

could u please tell me from which publication this book is available. Is it good for starters,who doesn't know anything about technical analysis OR starting with "Technical Analysis of Stock Trends BY Robert D. Edwards & John Magee" will be better.
Please suggest. Thanks....

Edwards & Magee is what people start with ,have not read the Gujral's book,however seems to be a "Mady Easy Model Question & Answer" usually we use to mug up before exam in hostel life.

rajatheroyal · #7 10th July 2008, 11:03 PM

i have read the book.It is useful for beginners only.The routine traders who already have knowledge about basic chartpattern and indicators need not buy this book.one more thing the book is actually written by Prasanna khemariya i think he might have used the name of aswini just to push up the sales.The book is not worth for its price rs 595 it has only 320 pages.This book is no match for the robert and magee book which contains 710 pages and the( price is same, only rs 595).i think aswini himself might not have read the book

it has so many printing errors

fire_gun · #8 11th July 2008, 10:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rajatheroyal

i have read the book.It is useful for beginners only.The routine traders who already have knowledge about basic chartpattern and indicators need not buy this book.one more thing the book is actually written by Prasanna khemariya i think he might have used the name of aswini just to push up the sales.The book is not worth for its price rs 595 it has only 320 pages.This book is no match for the robert and magee book which contains 710 pages and the( price is same, only rs 595).i think aswini himself might not have read the book

it has so many printing errors

and what about his 150+ charts claim in this book?? plzz tell some thing about that

rakeshluthra430 · #9 11th July 2008, 11:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fire_gun

and what about his 150+ charts claim in this book?? plzz tell some thing about that

Hi,
You will surely get more then 15 k charts if u diligently search the net. Also...as rightly pointed out by others here..it wont be worth spending so much for what is available free.
I suggest you read edward and magee first...pm me your email id... i will send you the book for free..i have the pdf version.

Rakesh

fire_gun · #10 11th July 2008, 12:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rakeshluthra430

Hi,
You will surely get more then 15 k charts if u diligently search the net. Also...as rightly pointed out by others here..it wont be worth spending so much for what is available free.
I suggest you read edward and magee first...pm me your email id... i will send you the book for free..i have the pdf version.

Rakesh

thanks i have already book "technical analysis of stock trends 8th edition "..but still looking for other books

..it helps