Trading with OBV - for Beginners only !!

deepsat

Active Member
Just keep in mind, any sarcasm or negative comments on obv or its followers is not tolerated. Posts are deleted and id is banned. Ur friend vs a bhai trolled obv followers so he was removed.

Only constructive criticism is allowed. Of course according to you it may be constructive but it can also be interpreted as personal attack.
E.g.. Suri ji said that in 200 ema method discretion is required, that was constructive criticism, but there was huge fight as it was perceived as personal attack.
God knows where is suri sir..:(

After 3 months now it is clear that suri ji was correct as discussion in my thread revealed that we can't be mechanical. You apologised... remember?
:lol::lol: Suri is still trying to understand what hit him. He is probably trying to understand the meaning of 'constructive criticism' and it might take years :rofl:

I remember xray telling in one of his OBV posts that 'price propels volume' in a casual way and that is his belief. But the thread owner started posting dozens of posts to tell that 'volume drives price' and it did not stop there. He started posting innuendos(indirect mentioning of posts that dint fall under his belief) and suddenly vanished. Came back again and vanished.Cycle is still continuing :D

I was crucified once as well for telling that the 'thread has run its course as there were more confusion and personal ego getting involved' and 'new variable is being added every week'. I saw nothing wrong in saying that as that is what was happening..everything is there in that thread. Nobody can deny that. Infact, i clearly told in that post that not every reader of the forum will understand the same way and people will ask questions. But, he dint like that as well.

I also mentioned that newbie/struggling traders are better off with mechanical system and any kind of discretion(or random inclusion of variables every week to show winning trades) is a suicide for them. Again, innuendos started (referring my post) and i stopped posting altogether.

So, any opinion against his belief has been ridiculed/laughed at/disparaged. All these ridiculing will definitely not solve the purpose of the thread(teaching/sharing) if that is the actual intention. And playing this threatening game that 'will never post anything again here' and returning back again after few weeks is the only lighter part of that thread :cool::)

So this is the lesson learned - never post anything questioning the holy indicator OBV (even with charts..nice examples of relinfra and SBI) .. Simple !!
 

aja

Well-Known Member
I'm not sure if Viju is profitable using OBV.
I think he should close this thread and continue posting in his main pivot-vwap thread.

*But if he is using OBV successfully then he should share few charts explaining it.

*upto his wish only.
 

mohan.sic

Well-Known Member
:lol::lol: Suri is still trying to understand what hit him. He is probably trying to understand the meaning of 'constructive criticism' and it might take years :rofl:

I remember xray telling in one of his OBV posts that 'price propels volume' in a casual way and that is his belief. But the thread owner started posting dozens of posts to tell that 'volume drives price' and it did not stop there. He started posting innuendos(indirect mentioning of posts that dint fall under his belief) and suddenly vanished. Came back again and vanished.Cycle is still continuing :D

I was crucified once as well for telling that the 'thread has run its course as there were more confusion and personal ego getting involved' and 'new variable is being added every week'. I saw nothing wrong in saying that as that is what was happening..everything is there in that thread. Nobody can deny that. Infact, i clearly told in that post that not every reader of the forum will understand the same way and people will ask questions. But, he dint like that as well.

I also mentioned that newbie/struggling traders are better off with mechanical system and any kind of discretion(or random inclusion of variables every week to show winning trades) is a suicide for them. Again, innuendos started (referring my post) and i stopped posting altogether.

So, any opinion against his belief has been ridiculed/laughed at/disparaged. All these ridiculing will definitely not solve the purpose of the thread(teaching/sharing) if that is the actual intention. And playing this threatening game that 'will never post anything again here' and returning back again after few weeks is the only lighter part of that thread :cool::)

So this is the lesson learned - never post anything questioning the holy indicator OBV (even with charts..nice examples of relinfra and SBI) .. Simple !!


Other than this i see only X ray's experiment thread on OBV and he is cool in replying. Who is person you are referring to and what thread.
 

vijkris

Learner and Follower
:lol:

Last few posts looks like people have simply released their emotions especially frustration and sadness.
All are not gifted teachers. But we need a genuine trader who can teach as well. There is no use of someone who teaches but cannot trade. I am part of another forum also, so I can make one comparison. Atleast in this forum all teachers are genuine traders.:clap:

Myself and monkeybusiness have same opinion that obv has to be included in the trading system. I have seen obv realtime, it gives advance info whether price will bo or bd. Enough time will be there to punch orders. So there is no point in thrashing obv.

Only in realtime tick data comes in and watching naked obv during that time is a different experience.
Just like bahubali 2 can be enjoyed in theatres, obv can be enjoyed in realtime only.

So please keep on working, this puzzle will be solved some day.:D
 

vijkris

Learner and Follower
varunkochhar has asked to close his thread. So, Vijay all guns training at you now:D
What did I do ?

To prevent confusion I stopped visiting that thread, so definitely I have not done anything which can hurt anyone.
in previous posts I just said that discretion is needed. Fully mechanical is not possible. This is in the context of 2 methods discussed in this thread. There are 3 or 4 more variations of obv, pdc,bo bd etc, which is beyond the scope of this thread as of now.
 

vijkris

Learner and Follower
I'm not sure if Viju is profitable using OBV.
I think he should close this thread and continue posting in his main pivot-vwap thread.

*But if he is using OBV successfully then he should share few charts explaining it.

*upto his wish only.
I am against the closure of this thread. I am quite sure there are few people who have understood the method and they will share it here.

Puchu's charts are an encouragement to everyone. :clap:

I am not worthy of Sharing any charts bro.:(
 

Similar threads