Buy/Sell Good System & Trand Filter AFL

N

nallan

Member
#11
#11
Hi All,

My friend has recently bought version 4.0 of stock maniacs.
It is all bullshit!

He went all out with enthusiasm with the system and endedup in losses.

If you back test the system, u will end up in losses all the time. When this question was posed to them, they said, it will not work for rangebound market.
But unfortunately always we get mixed rangebound and trending days
never it is simple range bound nor trending.

instead as already suggested in this forum, i tried to trade in 315 cross over as mentioned in other links. and combined with stochastics, and RSI and MACD and devised i started going long or short based on 315 crossover and exit at stochastics cross over and I see RSI also if exitingon selling( considering <50% as appropriate.)

With this i am able to make better trade.
Tstochmaniacs have introduced anotther trend filter for hourly time frame it appears it is also eyewash.
My advise for all is not not to pay for any system and develop ur own with available free systems and enjoy after back testing the system designed by you.

even simple 315 combined with stochastics cross over will give very good benefits if followed strictly

whipsaws are inevitable and try to reduce them by using filters
 
T

tonictone1980

New Member
#12
#12
Just type Nifty Intraday Trading System In youtube & will find some live market recorded videos...I watched it and was quite impressed as all those had been recorded in live market and also its in continous series....just have a look
 
Last edited:
W

worldastro

Active Member
#13
#13
nallan said:
Hi All,

My friend has recently bought version 4.0 of stock maniacs.
It is all bullshit!

He went all out with enthusiasm with the system and endedup in losses.

If you back test the system, u will end up in losses all the time. When this question was posed to them, they said, it will not work for rangebound market.
But unfortunately always we get mixed rangebound and trending days
never it is simple range bound nor trending.

instead as already suggested in this forum, i tried to trade in 315 cross over as mentioned in other links. and combined with stochastics, and RSI and MACD and devised i started going long or short based on 315 crossover and exit at stochastics cross over and I see RSI also if exitingon selling( considering <50% as appropriate.)

With this i am able to make better trade.
Tstochmaniacs have introduced anotther trend filter for hourly time frame it appears it is also eyewash.
My advise for all is not not to pay for any system and develop ur own with available free systems and enjoy after back testing the system designed by you.

even simple 315 combined with stochastics cross over will give very good benefits if followed strictly

whipsaws are inevitable and try to reduce them by using filters
Click to expand...
what is the " simple 315 combined with stochastics cross over " ?????
plese picture and detail plese !!!!!!
 
K

KANCHRAPRA

New Member
#15
#15
nallan said:
Hi All,

My friend has recently bought version 4.0 of stock maniacs.
It is all bullshit!

He went all out with enthusiasm with the system and endedup in losses.

If you back test the system, u will end up in losses all the time. When this question was posed to them, they said, it will not work for rangebound market.
But unfortunately always we get mixed rangebound and trending days
never it is simple range bound nor trending.

instead as already suggested in this forum, i tried to trade in 315 cross over as mentioned in other links. and combined with stochastics, and RSI and MACD and devised i started going long or short based on 315 crossover and exit at stochastics cross over and I see RSI also if exitingon selling( considering <50% as appropriate.)

With this i am able to make better trade.
Tstochmaniacs have introduced anotther trend filter for hourly time frame it appears it is also eyewash.
My advise for all is not not to pay for any system and develop ur own with available free systems and enjoy after back testing the system designed by you.

even simple 315 combined with stochastics cross over will give very good benefits if followed strictly

whipsaws are inevitable and try to reduce them by using filters
Click to expand...
with all respect to nallan's friend, i am using their systems for last 1 year and am quite satisfied with their timely updates. i am much benefited from the trend filters. it did not seem to be an eyewash to me. it really works well to differentiate between sideways and trending market. may be nallan's friend cud not understand the usage properly, but those maniacs people have conducted a nice training session for me. rgds
 
A

anandmurale

New Member
#17
#17
If possible post AFL. Any mod and better result can b ached will try to help it out. U can mail me also if u wish at anandmurale yahoo co in.Wt possible to max extent will try to help it out. bye
 
N

nl100

New Member
#18
#18
I would like to have this stockmaniac 4.0 can you pls send it to nl100 at rediffmail
No AFL will work for all situations because if you watch closely you will notice two things 1) gap up and gap down everyday in the beginning of market hours, and this distorts the calculations of EMA.MA etc. Gap up and Gap down cannot be predicted by a trading system as it depends entirely on world markets 2) sudden raise and sudden falls due to some news, these are similar to gap up and gap down
These force us to have judgement on top of trading system recommendations.
Sellers of trading systems make tall claims and show us only those charts that have clicked. If this stockmaniac fellow had developed a perfect system he would have become a billionaire by now.
Anyways, please do share latest version. Let us see.
 
rajsumi121

rajsumi121

Well-Known Member
#19
#19
_SECTION_BEGIN("filter");
Buy = Close > EMA(Close,21) AND PDI(14) > MDI(14) AND ADX(14) > 25;
Sell = Close < EMA(Close,21) AND PDI(14) < MDI(14) AND ADX(14) > 25;
Filter = Buy OR Sell;
AddColumn(Close,"close");
_SECTION_END();




check for filter
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
T Help Needed to fix buy and sell Arrow (intraday trading system with back test result attached) AmiBroker 1
jash_kd I have made a new Buy Sell signal system, Plz test it AmiBroker 3
S need help for auto-trading system triggered by buy/sell signal AmiBroker 2
P anybody have traderxbuy-sell-trading-system AmiBroker 11
S New jackpot systems buy sell nifty AmiBroker 9

Similar threads